MovieChat Forums > Halloween (2018) Discussion > Judy Greer as her daughter?

Judy Greer as her daughter?


Okay besides the change of actor from Danielle Harris and the change of character from Jamie to supposedly Karen, I don’t care for this.

Mainly because it makes it feel too predictable. That well known of an actor, and playing Laurie’s daughter, do you really think there’s any chance of this character dying? Oh they’ll give her suspenseful moments to be sure, but she already has too much plot armor. My money says this means they’ll give Laurie a proper, dramatic send-off death (her death in Resurrection was fine, but as the prologue to one of the worst entries, really?), and then they’ll want Greer to carry the franchise, at least for an entry or two (because you’re kidding yourself if you think any entry in a horror franchise is actually intended as the definitive end, especially since they apparently all get multiple timelines now), which I feel would be a mistake. I realize I’m only speculating, and far out, but hard not to. Nothing against Greer, I think she’s a decent actor and she could very well prove me wrong, but I don’t feel like horror is quite a good fit for her, and if I’m right about their plans for her, that’s a lot of weight on her shoulders. I’d rather have them only have Jamie Lee Curtis, and other than her, have complete/mostly unknowns like back in the day. Would help give it a grittier feel too I think, that I bet the film will lack, it will more likely look like the glossier, more recent entries.

Don’t get me wrong, totally stoked to see it, just not wild about this piece of news.

reply

I'm really excited for it. Will be cool to see a proper sequel to the first 2. Will be a fun movie to watch with a big crowd of people!

reply

I’m a bit torn. I kinda fancy the idea of Greer as Laurie’s daughter... if it’s handled well. At the same time, I’m reluctant to see what it can potentially mean for the series because, yes, I also wouldn’t be stoked to see her carry the torch. (And honestly, I would like to see Laurie survive once again.) Fair to say the aspect of Greer feeling out of place in this can be a cause for concern, but... you never know, Greer might prove to be a natural fit. I genuinely want to see what she can bring to the movie.

Moreoever, while I want to agree with you on mostly unknowns staring alongside Curtis, seeing other well-known faces (real actors, not pop stars) would be fine as long as, again, it’s done right. And with the talent involved in this, the right gritty tone should be expected. Come what may, I’m pumped.

reply

With this news, I wouldn't mind a mother/daughter dance scene modeled after Jamie Lee Curtis' in True Lies.

reply