MovieChat Forums > Slumdog Millionaire (2008) Discussion > I don't think this was better than The D...

I don't think this was better than The Dark Knight


Really great movie definitely deserving a nomination for best motion picture of the year, but The Dark Knight was a superior film and got robbed of at least a nomination.

reply

That's true, I liked the dark knight a lot and thought it deserved something.

_________________________
http://youtu.be/GAIJ3Rh5Qxs

reply

[deleted]

Agree 100%.

Slumdog is worthwhile to watch, but was definitely over-hyped when it won. Dark Knight felt fresh, innovative, smart, and exciting. Almost the perfect movie.

Also robbed was The Wrestler, which should have won out of the 5 nominated. That movie was brilliant and stayed with me long after I watched it. But I guess because it wasn't connected with any trendy issues, it wasn't a contender to win.

I'm still puzzled how Slumdog received THREE song nominations while Bruce Springsteen's song was completely shut out.

reply

The Dark Knight is very good but Slumdog Millionaire I would probably put in my top 10 movies of all time.

I do think it's better but TDK is very good too.

reply

Have you only seen seven movies?

reply

I think Dark Knight deserved a nomination, but it's hard to argue Slumdog winning.

reply

I can't agree. I've always felt like the Dark Knight series was particularly overrated and taken much more seriously than it was worth. The Dark Knight was a good action movie that was ambitious to try and transcend its comic book origins, but it still didn't end up being as thought provoking and consistently entertaining as Slumdog Millionaire.

They don't call me Col. Homer cause I'm some dumbass army guy!

reply

BINGO.

totally agree.

imo the fuel that carried dark knight was the hype surrounding christopher nolan (deserved btw) and the mass shooting that occurred in colorado. the film received massive publicity from that. people mistake popularity with quality. yes DK was a well made film but it's still a comic book movie.


i dare say had the shooting not happened it would've had regular if not marginal levels of viewership/notariety.

reply

Troll rating 1/10. Lol a movie about a comic book character a better movie then a gritty dark masterpiece.

Dark knight at best is an average film. Way overrated and not worthy of a nomination.





Lawrence of Arbia, he was an English guy who came to fight the Turkish

reply

bingo again. yep, agreed.

reply

This movie is truly amazing and touching movie. The Dark Knight was good, but it has brilliant performance by Hedger, that's all.

reply

No way was this movie better.

reply

What a profound argument. Well, that settles everything, then.

reply

Right back at you. Your analyses of both movies are spot on.

Blocked.

reply

Let’s see: You entire “argument” consists of “No way was this movie better.” Period. No statement of how it was inferior to TDK. No statement of how TDK was superior to SM. “It’s just better, so there. Ny-ny-ny-na-ny-ny.” Please do not reproduce yourself, though I doubt the chances of that anyway.

PS, Einstein: I did not analyze either movie. I said that your post was puerile and contained no actual argument.

reply