MovieChat Forums > Gone Baby Gone (2007) Discussion > Amy Ryan or Blake Lively?

Amy Ryan or Blake Lively?


Amy Ryan as Helene in this or Blake Lively as Krista in "The Town". Which one gave the best portrayal as a Boston Skank?

I think Ben has a thing for Boston Skanks, because they both play them perfectly.

"He's not Judge Judy and executioner!"

reply

Amy Ryan

reply

AMY RYAN BY FAR...SHE LATER STOLE MINE AND MICHAEL SCOTT'S HEARTS AS HOLLY ON THE OFFICE.

reply

Amy Ryan was much more impressive, I didn’t find Blake Lively convincing at all tbh.

reply

Blake Lively was very good, easily the best thing about The Town, a film I have mostly forgotten in the years since, but she cannot hold a candle to Amy Ryan, who is simply mesmerising in Gone Baby Gone.

reply

Amy Ryan by a mile.

reply

Amy Ryan

reply