Film doesn't make sense


How could Crowe possibly not realize he's dead until the very end? The few coincidences in the movie that fool the viewer into thinking he's alive (he happens to be sitting facing a living person, tricking the reader into thinking they can see and hear each other; he calls to his wife to answer the doorbell, and we can't see her lack of reaction because she is upstairs) would not have kept Crowe himself fooled over all the months following the home invasion/shooting, because there would have been hundreds and thousands of instances where he tried to interact with a living person. He would have quickly picked up on the fact that they cannot see or hear him.

reply

The rule for him and other dead people Cole sees is that they see only what they want to see. Crowe only sees things the way he wants to see them. Just like the other ghosts he encounters.

reply

This. He's in denial. He denies it every time he tries to open that door to the basement, but the reality is that he can't.

reply

Lots of people are dead but don't realize it. And he could talk to the kid. And he thought his wife was just tuning him out and being distant because he was so absorbed in his work.

But yeah, some of the other dead people he talked to knew they were dead, and wanted him to do something for them that they couldn't do.

reply

And the entire time he never tried to talk to anyone else? Not even Cole's mother? In fact, why would he be there? Obviously, Cole's mother could not have hired him.

reply

Cole clearly draws ghosts who try to ascribe a certain role to him (patient, friend, husband) to make sense of his presence.

I also think we shouldn't assume Malcolm was constantly aware of time and space, otherwise people who have been dead for centuries would've noticed they're dead a long time ago. A lot of the ghosts seem to be stuck in some kind of trauma or event from their lives.

reply

I feel sorry for the hanged family. Imagine your afterlife being that way, suspended by the neck for all eternity, no pain but being utterly helpless.

reply

It saddens me that you lack the required perception to fully appreciate this movie.

reply