MovieChat Forums > Siskel & Ebert & the Movies (1986) Discussion > What are some examples of Roger Ebert's ...

What are some examples of Roger Ebert's reviews disagreeing with whatever the ‘consensus’ was?

posted 2 years ago by TMC-4 (19458)
3 replies | jump to latest

What are some movies that most people disliked but Ebert actually really enjoyed? What about ‘great’ movies that Ebert didn’t like?

[–] blue1981 (6551) 2 years ago

Siskel and Ebert were notoriously harsh towards a lot of horror movies that were beloved by fans. Look up the reviews of the Friday the 13th movies and I remember them really hating Silent Night Deadly Night. A lot of horror movies were not made for critics but when they gave them negative reviews they came off like elitist pricks.

[–] Wuchak (8184) 2 years ago

Here are several examples:

- Siskel gave "Coming to America" a thumbs-up while Ebert gave it a thumbs-down.
- Siskel gave "Apocalypse Now" a thumbs-down (but changed his mind years later) while Ebert gave it a thumbs-up.
- Siskel gave "Dead Poets Society" a thumbs-up while Ebert gave it a thumbs-down.
- Siskel gave "Terminator" a thumbs-down while Ebert gave it a thumbs-up.
- Siskel gave "The Island of Dr. Moreau" (1996) a thumbs-up while Ebert gave it a thumbs-down

[–] ebhaynz (3550) 2 years ago

Ebert notoriously didn't like My Cousin Vinny, here's the controversial review:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqZksBt9k4Q