This film was HORRIBLE!!!


First, I love Christmas movies. I recorded this off of the Hallmark channel a few days ago, I can't believe I sat thorugh this CRAP of a movie. The film was SO FRIGGING dark, it was harldy enjoyable. The actors looked like they were as bored as can be and the story was way to depressing. There are way too many loose ends that are never explained and the film does not deliver in it's ending. I was shocked to hear all of the positive reviews for this film but to each his own. The best Christmas movie to come out recently has been The Polar Express. Steer clear from this one folks!

reply

Says the Transformers hipster, smh. This movie is pretty good.

Bruce Lee was real. Batman was never real.

reply

I love One Magic Christmas. First saw it as a kid and have loved it ever since. Polar Express was boring and dull. Even the kids I watched it with couldn't make it to the end it was so boring. I really question someone's movie op for favoring such a cheesy movie over this great one.

reply

I wouldn't call it horrible. It tried to tell a good story, and it had a nice, heartwarming ending. But I DID get mad at it, yelling at the screen many times during the entire ridiculous "my husband and maybe kids are dead" nonsense.

I get they were trying to go for their own take on the "It's a Wonderful Life" type of "What if she didn't have her family, maybe then she'd realize how lucky she is to have them" theme. But I don't think they needed to go QUITE where they did, it got very dark there for a bit. And the whole angel/santa/letter bit just added to how convoluted it felt.

But I still wouldn't call it a bad movie. Just a messy one.

reply

People loved the film because it was a lesson in appreciating what you have, rather than hating the world because things didn't go your way. It even has a Christian allegory, if you know where to look buried in the writing. Like Ginny was worthy of saving from her own misery.

Plus, people really only watch the movie for three things: the cute kids, the Santa scenes, and the part after Ginny puts the letter in the mailbox and gets her husband back, and she celebrates Christmas with her family.

reply

The plot have been seen as downbeat and depressing but I still think its a good movie.

reply

I'll admit that before the time-warp scene, where Ginny actually brings her husband back by mailing her daughter's letter to Santa; the film stinks. But the problem is, if you watch only half the film, none of it makes sense. You don't learn to appreciate why Ginny has a change of heart, or why things went better the next time the same day played out.

And yeah, they left the ending very ambiguous, forcing you to use your imagination on what happened to the family after Christmas.

reply

The difference being in One Magic Christmas the little girl Abby visits the North Pole and the Santa is probably the most authentic Santas Ive ever seen on film and you'd think he was real. One Magic Christmas is a great movie.

reply