Language Ananchronisms


I haven't been keeping close tabs on this but here are a few of the most egregious examples along with a surprising one.

In a Season 2 (I think) episode, Mingo uses the term "psychological advantage," which I was surprised actually was in use in the 1700s and he could have picked up in his Oxford studies.

Season 2, Episode 6 is entitled "The Trek," and the word is used in dialogue. "Trek" is a South African word and would not have been heard on the American frontier.

Season 3, episode 10: Except for a Season 1 episode where Yadkin said something which might or might not have been "Okay," this is the first time I have heard a clear use of "Okay" in this series. It was first used in 1839 but not in wide use until later.

I also heard "shut up" a whole lot of times, particularly in one episode in which they used it constantly, which supposedly dates from 1840 but is said to have been used in Shakespeare's King Lear and earlier sources.

I'm sure there are plenty more; these are the ones which stood out.

reply

Season 3, Episode 24, "The Necklace": Second use of "okay" and several "shut up"s.

Another thing I've noticed on this show is sometimes currency is given in pounds and sometimes in dollars. This episode actually uses both. The American dollar was not introduced until 1792 and in this episode they are (again) fighting the American Revolution (much earlier), after taking a few detours into the late 1700s-early 1800s. Maybe the dollar followed them back.

reply

The Continental Congress started printing dollars in 1775.
Before that there were Spanish milled dollars that had been around for more than a century and frequently used in the colonies, being brought in because of the trade with the Spanish islands of the Caribbean.
The dollar printed by the Continental Congress was based on and assigned a value equivalent to the Spanish dollar.

reply

Thanks, I didn't know that.

reply

Season 4, episode 2: two "okay"s in one episode, both from Israel.

reply

It wouldn't take much to hire somebody to check this kind of stuff, but I don't think they care, and most of the audience doesn't know the difference. I was watching "Sons of Liberty" a few years ago and the dialogue had Ben Franklin say "batshit crazy". I couldn't take it anymore. Turned it off.

reply

An English teacher told me that sort of thing happened on Little House on the Prairie all the time. I tended to notice other mistakes, such as that baseball had been invented when they showed a game being played, but baseball gloves had not and they were using them. Referring to a girls' basketball team before boys' basketball was even invented. I barely had to get out of my chair to reach for the World Book to confirm these mistakes, but apparently they couldn't afford a set of the World Book. On an episode I saw the other day, "Entrance of the Gladiators" op. 68 or "Entry of the Gladiators" (Czech: Vjezd gladiátorů), a military march composed in 1897 by the Czech composer Julius Fučík, was played when a circus came to town. Laura was born in 1867 so should have been about thirty when this music was written. In this episode she was in her early teens if that.

I wonder if Ben Franklin would have used that phrase had he ever heard it.

reply

Season 4, episode 11: one more "Okay."

reply

Season 4, episode 17: two more "okay"s. Israel likes "okay" better than "criminently." Of course it is ubiquitous in the language now, in fact, inescapable.

reply

Season 4, episode 18, two more "okay"s.

reply

In another genre, I alway laugh at contractions used in biblical times show/films, or ancient Roman/Greek films etc. (i.e. don’t, doesn’t etc)

reply

That's interesting. I always laugh because they tend not to use contractions in biblical/ancient Roman/Greek films. I think it's likely that speakers of the various Mediterranean and Middle Eastern languages of those periods used contractions. Of course, in the movies the actors are speaking modern English, but not using contractions makes them sound stilted.

reply

Season 5, episode 15: one "Okay."

reply