MovieChat Forums > El Cid (1961) Discussion > Ranks with the best sword & sandal epics

Ranks with the best sword & sandal epics


"El Cid" is curiously obscure compared to other classic sword & sandal epics, like “The Ten Commandments” (1956), “Ben-Hur” (1959) and “Spartacus” (1960), but it’s just as great and on par with the more modern “Troy” (2004), not to mention superior to the overrated “Braveheart” (1995) and “Gladiator” (2000). Even if you disagree with me on those last two films, “El Cid” stands well with any of these epics.

I knew enough about Rodrigo’s real-life story to know that the political intrigue gets convoluted and wondered if the movie could keep everything understandable and compelling for the course of three hours; and it does (unlike 2005’s “Kingdom of Heaven”). Just before the drama overstays its welcome a quality action scene manifests, Like Rodrigo’s thrilling duel with Jimena’s father. I also appreciated the subtext of dealing with flawed people in leadership positions and overcoming resentment to have effective working relationships.

For those who object to Heston being cast as a Spaniard, the Castilian aristocracy of the 11th Century was generally Visigoth in ethnic background, aka German. Despite the regular influx of people of color ever since, there are plenty of Blond Spaniards to this day, even redheads. (Remember, Spain is decidedly Europe and not Mexico).

reply

My mother was from Spain, and she was a brunette with blue eyes. 😁

The movie doesn't follow Rodrigo's real life story, but the story as was written in the 'Cantar'. The 'Cantar del Mio Cid' (Song of My Cid) was the most famous oral story during the Middle Ages in Spain. It's loosely based in real life, with more or less drama added depending on the part (the trial scene was mostly made up, for example).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cantar_de_mio_Cid

As an anecdote, the story of Song of My Cid was deeply researched by Menendez Pidal, one of the most important Spanish historians and essayists, who holds the (unfortunate) record of being the person who has been nominated more times to the Nobel Prize... without getting it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramón_Menéndez_Pidal

reply

Yes. It may be my age but this was regularly on TV once and I think everyone one I know will know this film - so I don't think it's obscure at all.

reply

I don't doubt you, but that hasn't been my experience. When the topic of the best sword & sandal epics comes up, those other ones are cited, but rarely "El Cid." So I was surprised by how good it was when I finally viewed it a few nights ago.

reply

It was the fourth highest grossing film of 1961, so pretty much anyone who was of movie-going age in '61 would know of the movie even if they didn't see it.

reply

They really don't talk about this one much, which is so weird, but it is definitely up there.

reply