MovieChat Forums > Donald Trump Discussion > Trump v US: SCOTUS likely to determine p...

Trump v US: SCOTUS likely to determine presidents get ‘some amount’ of immunity, experts say


https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trump-us-scotus-determine-presidents-get-some-amount-immunity-experts

The Supreme Court is set to consider arguably the highest-profile cases of the term Thursday to determine whether former President Trump can claim presidential immunity against criminal charges brought by the Biden Justice Department.

Special Counsel Jack Smith, who brought charges against Trump following his investigation into the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol riot and Trump's alleged plot to overturn the 2020 election result, argued in briefs submitted to the high court that "presidents are not above the law."

Trump's legal team conversely argued, "A denial of criminal immunity would incapacitate every future President…[t]he threat of future prosecution and imprisonment would become a political cudgel to influence the most sensitive and controversial decisions, taking away the strength, authority, and decisiveness of the Presidency."

"Legal experts told Fox News Digital that while all nine justices might be skeptical of Trump's sweeping immunity claims, they are likely to give guidance on where presidential immunity from criminal prosecution ends for actions taken while in the Oval Office – which could have a profound impact in the criminal cases against the former president."

Similarly, Trusty said he expects the court to "give very little credit to the notion of absolutely unlimited immunity, as President Trump’s lawyers have argued."

"But I do think there is a strong possibility that the court confirms the notion that immunity protects the president and that their ruling could set in motion the eventual dismissal of the Jan. 6, Mar-a-Lago and Georgia cases," he said.

The Supreme Court will hear the case, Trump v. United States, on Thursday at 10 a.m."


Folks, I've said this countless times and the usual liberal pundits around here won't believe this when I say, the U.S Supreme Court will rule Jan 6th, 2021 was not, NOT an Insurrection and instead, was nothing more than a "Riot" by definition when Trump wasn't even present.. Sorry, it's going to be a hard pill to swallow and we might even see some liberals on suicide watch over it like the Pinheads at MSNBC, but just because the Left & Liberals say it was an Insurrection, doesn't make it so.. The only reason we're even seeing this is because Trump is running for President and is poised to win in November and this is their way of stopping him..

reply

Scumbag refuses to accept election result
orders army of dancing monkeys into capitol building to "resist" aka change the result

There no way any immunity covers that
and the fact that he cannot accept reality even before the jan6th circus shows he is not fit to be president.

Presidents need to be NOT CRAZY ie not think they can change reality by crying about it stamping their feet and positing bullshit on their private "Truth" echo chamber

reply

You're really going to have a hard time with this I see when the Verdict does come back that it just wasn't an Insurrection like you claim?? What else needs to be said?? And you can't possibly believe to this day that Joe Biden got 81 Million votes while sitting in his basement for 9 months sporting a mask and social distancing with his wife and yet, he STILL comes down with Covid even after all of that further proving that the wearing of the masks and the social distancing crap never worked.. I suppose one could say that you had the people stupid enough to vote with the mindset of "I'm not voting for Biden, I'm voting against Trump" mentality and as a result, look how bad the last 4 Years have been thanks to that mindset??

reply

I think I'll handle it
is the "insurrection or riot" question separate ?

Are/will/have they charged him with inciting a riot ? (if insurrection is a no go?)

reply

The man has simply never been charged and this is what we've been saying for like the last 3 Years!!

reply

just done some googling ...
https://www.npr.org/2023/08/01/1191493880/trump-january-6-charges-indictment-counts


one count of conspiracy to defraud the United States applies to Trump's repeated and widespread efforts to spread false claims about the November 2020 election while knowing they were not true and for allegedly attempting to illegally discount legitimate votes all with the goal of overturning the 2020 election, prosecutors claim in the indictment.

one count of conspiracy to obstruct an official proceeding was brought due to the alleged organized planning by Trump and his allies to disrupt the electoral vote's certification in January 2021.

one count of obstruction of and attempt to obstruct an official proceeding is tied to Trump and his co-conspirators' alleged efforts after the November 2020 election until Jan. 7, 2021, to block the official certification proceeding in Congress.

one count of conspiracy against rights refers to Trump and his co-conspirators alleged attempts to "oppress, threaten and intimidate" people in their right to vote in an election.


That sounds like treason and insurrection to me .
Whether they actually call it that doesn't matter given that they have actually charged him with the above
Which sound to me like very serious crimes

I kinda share the maga view that shushing pornstars and lying to get loans isnt really that bad , but this stuff is.

reply

Yeah, Um, from NPR no less, but whatever floats your boat I suppose??

reply

MAGA Excuse list
-Libturds control everything
-False Flag
-Fake News
-What about the other guy
-TDS
-We were only joking, it was satire

going for number 3 ?
brave choice.
So you are saying that NPR have in fact made up those indictments and its not true?
Did you see the detailed PDF of the actual court documents on the page?
You'd have been better sticking with #5

reply

What about the other guy?? Your side is the one who plays this "Victimhood" crap ever since Covid.. It's everyone else's fault on the right.

reply

How so? the right's victim complex complains the left secretly control everything
Dems are in control of list:
-Hollywood
-Media
-Silicon Valley
-Police
-Courts
-FBI
-AI
-CIA


What are the left playing victim about 'ever since covid' ?

reply

scumbags refused to accept the 2016 results. then a army of dancing monkeys told Mueller to investigate to find collusion, he did not find any. then the Durham report concluded all the "evidence" presented in the Mueller report was fake.

Hillary and her minions went on to cry said the election was stolen from her.

reply

once vs amillion times and staging a coup about it

reply

it was just once by me, and no one is saying the 2016 election was stolen on MC.

it was a mostly peaceful protest against a fraudulent election. dems did the same thing in 2016.

reply

Why would Trump need immunity if he's certain to be found not guilty of anything?

An emphasis on immunity is generally considered an admission of guilt.

reply

This is true

reply