MovieChat Forums > Donald Trump Discussion > BREAKING: Mueller livid at AG William Ba...

BREAKING: Mueller livid at AG William Barr for misrepresenting and censoring his report.


Special counsel Robert S. Mueller III wrote a letter in late March lambasting Attorney General William P. Barr that a four-page memo to Congress describing the principal conclusions of the investigation into President Trump “did not fully capture the context, nature, and substance” of Mueller’s work, according to a copy of the letter reviewed Tuesday by The Washington Post.

The letter and a subsequent phone call between the two men reveal the degree to which the longtime colleagues and friends disagreed as they handled the legally and politically fraught task of investigating the president. Democrats in Congress are likely to scrutinize Mueller’s complaints to Barr as they contemplate the prospect of opening impeachment proceedings and mull how hard to press for Mueller himself to testify publicly.

At the time Mueller’s letter was sent to Barr on March 27, Barr had days prior announced that Mueller did not find a conspiracy between the Trump campaign and Russian officials seeking to interfere in the 2016 presidential election. In his memo to Congress, Barr also said that Mueller had not reached a conclusion about whether Trump had tried to obstruct justice, but that Barr reviewed the evidence and found it insufficient to support such a charge.

Days after Barr’s announcement, Mueller wrote the previously undisclosed private letter to the Justice Department, laying out his concerns in stark terms that shocked senior Justice Department officials, according to people familiar with the discussions.

“The summary letter the Department sent to Congress and released to the public late in the afternoon of March 24 did not fully capture the context, nature, and substance of this office’s work and conclusions,” Mueller wrote. “There is now public confusion about critical aspects of the results of our investigation. This threatens to undermine a central purpose for which the Department appointed the Special Counsel: to assure full public confidence in the outcome of the investigations.”

The letter made a key request: that Barr release the 448-page report’s introductions and executive summaries, and it made initial suggested redactions for doing so, according to Justice Department officials.

Justice Department officials said Tuesday that they were taken aback by the tone of Mueller’s letter and that it came as a surprise to them that he had such concerns. Until they received the letter, they believed Mueller was in agreement with them on the process of reviewing the report and redacting certain types of information, a process that took several weeks. Barr has testified to Congress previously that Mueller declined the opportunity to review his four-page memo to lawmakers that distilled the essence of the special counsel’s findings.

Democrats are looking for a plan of attack with the release of the redacted Mueller report and Attorney General Barr’s upcoming congressional testimonies. (Blair Guild/The Washington Post)

In his letter to Barr, Mueller wrote that the redaction process “need not delay release of the enclosed materials. Release at this time would alleviate the misunderstandings that have arisen and would answer congressional and public questions about the nature and outcome of our investigation.”

A day after Mueller sent his letter to Barr, the two men spoke by phone for about 15 minutes, according to law enforcement officials.

In that call, Mueller said he was concerned that media coverage of the obstruction investigation was misguided and creating public misunderstandings about the office’s work, according to Justice Department officials. Mueller did not express similar concerns about the public discussion of the investigation of Russia’s election interference, the officials said.

In their call, Barr also took issue with Mueller calling his memo a “summary,” saying he had never intended to summarize the voluminous report, but instead provide an account of its top conclusions, officials said.

Some senior Justice Department officials were frustrated by Mueller’s complaints because they had expected that the report would reach them with proposed redactions, but it did not. Even when Mueller sent along his suggested redactions, those covered only a few areas of protected information, and the documents required further review, these people said.

The Washington Post and the New York Times had previously reported some members of Mueller’s team were frustrated with Barr’s characterization of their work, though Mueller’s own attitude was unknown before now. In some team members’ view, the evidence they had gathered — especially on obstruction — was far more alarming and significant than how Barr had described it.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/mueller-complained-that-barrs-letter-did-not-capture-context-of-trump-probe/2019/04/30/d3c8fdb6-6b7b-11e9-a66d-a82d3f3d96d5_story.html

reply

Kind of a moot point, no? Report is summarized in a 4-page memo, released full to public in redacted form, AG Barr may or may not go to judicial hearing even under subpoena, Rosenstein resigned as he said he would once the investigation concluded.

reply

That memo was Barr's summary at odds with what Mueller wrote for public release.

reply

This is Mueller himself saying that Barr's 4-page memo was wrong and Barr has refused to release his key summaries of the report.

How can that be moot? This is explosive. Another term for it is a "cover-up".

Who cares if a proven liar like Barr refuses to testify?

All that matters is Mueller's testimony now.

reply

There are already calls for Barr's resignation. Tomorrow should be a crazy eventful day.

reply

He's right Rory, this is dynamite. I called it over a month ago, this is the Saturday Night Massacre 2.0 because this shit is really blowing up.

Bill Barr clearly lied to congress when he claimed he didn't know what Mueller thought of his 4-page memo.

It's an all out attempted cover-up.

reply

I just caught up with the news. Saw the letter from Mueller expressing his frustration on Barr's. Yeah, I see the issue now.

reply

This is so awesome, shit is just hitting the fan up-down-sideways. It's gory.

It really sets up such a delicious showdown when Mueller testifies.

Republicans really dug their graves on this one, because what are they going to do when Mueller goes before congress and, like in his letter, calls out Bill Barr for being the liar that he is?

Will the lying smear merchants of the GOP; Devin Nunes, Matt Gaetz, Jim Jordan, Mark Meadows ... are they really going to try and smear the decorated war vet and lifelong Republican they were all praising when he was appointed 24 months ago? Are they going to question Mueller's integrity and instead side with the proven liar Bill Barr? They'll just be marginalizing themselves if they do.

This is going to be one of those no holds Barred political barroom brawls and the stakes will be for the entire pile and future of our country. The winners will rule and the losers will lose and surely go to jail. If Dems win then we'll see Nixon's Saturday Night Massacre redux where Trump will resign and his corrupt stooge AG Bill Barr will go to jail much like Nixon's corrupt Attorney General John Mitchell did 45 years ago for trying to cover up his boss's crimes.

If Dems don't do the right thing and press full political advantage of this moment they will get crushed by the GOP sharks. It will mean Bill Barr will be free to snuff out one-by-one all the investigations Mueller left in the hands of SDNY to prosecute Trump and his crime family. It will surely mean Bill Barr is going to witch hunt the fuck out of the poor sods in the FBI/CIA/NSA that dared initiate the counterintel investigation into Trump based on legit intel from our foreign allies. If I were them I'd be really worried about this right now and start leaking like crazy.

Dems suck at politics compared to Republicans so even though they have the upper hand right now I only give them a 50-50 shot of being able to max the most of it. The Mueller testimony is looking like the cataclysm.

reply

Here's what I want to know: just WHAT is Donald offering all these stooges to sell their souls to him? It's alarming. It's like a kamikaze band of Trump officials fully ready, willing and even eager to fall on the sword and do hard time for Donald and with seemingly no regrets. Why? Why are THAT many people willing to self-destruct their very lives, integrity and freedoms for this infantile, 72-year old manbaby?

reply

He's offering them his "protection" and the opportunity to join the cool kid's club.

That's really what it comes down to.

reply

[deleted]

What do you think is going to happen, eYeDEF? Ultimately? Will Trump resign like Nixon? I HIGHLY doubt it. Trump is too goddamned stubborn and full of himself to do that.

What do you think?

reply

Not yet. But this will be remembered as a historic day in American history.

Trump insiders were giddy in advance of Barr’s arrival, saying Mueller would be gone soon and Trump finally had an AG who was "on his side". That was clearly completely accurate. As we predicted, Barr showed today he’s a shameless Trump stooge and will be there until the bitter end.

What's amazing is Bill Barr WAS one of those beyond reproach, highly respected GOP daddy figures in DC. Not a Matt Whitaker or Giuliani clown, he was previously one of those respectable and deferred to credentialed DC power lawyer types. We among the chattering classes knew for months that wasn’t a deserved reputation. But it was his reputation. The fact that he was able to con most of the DC press (to our infinite frustration) with his letter for weeks was testament to that fact. Finally Trump had one of those guys making his "no collusion, no obstruction, witchhunt!" arguments for him, practically word for word. For Trump Barr was like manna from heaven.

Beyond having an un-recused toady running the DoJ, Barr's reputation was immensely important to Trump more than most people realize. The best metaphor I've seen is Trump is Gollum and the respect of respectable people are his elusive "precious". Barr remains useful to Trump. The covering up and defiance of congress will continue. But Barr’s reputation is in tatters. He's now officially damaged goods like most others Trump has used up. Of course Republicans aren’t saying that. They love him. They’ll defend him. But they can see the obvious as clearly as anyone. Bill Barr is just a straight up liar. He’ll say anything for his master. His word means nothing. And that is something even many Democrats in the DC bubble and too many Washington journalists didn’t understand until today.

In other words, the schmuck has been marginalized in his own DoJ.

reply

And now the schmuck is ducking out of today's scheduled testimony. What do you think will develop from that?

reply

Further testimony from Barr is irrelevant and gratuitous at this point. He's already proven himself to be a shameless liar. What good is his testimony? They've already caught him in a ton of lies.

The point of congressional testimony is discovery. There's nothing more to discover with Barr, he's already thoroughly discredited himself and he's not going to give us any new info. All I cared about was the DC press and Democrats in their precious bubble finally waking up to this fact that Barr can't be taken seriously for anything. He's another John Mitchell.

He also demonstrated yesterday he hasn't even read the Mueller report that he was somehow able to render a verdict on. At least he claimed not to have read it when pointedly asked by Kamala Harris.

It was also telling how Barr didn't hold back on criticizing anyone including piling on Mueller. Yet the one guy he refused to criticize was Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska, the Putin agent the Trump campaign secretly gave proprietary polling data to as the Kremlin was trying to target American voters with disinformation and that Trump has specifically made a sanctions exemption for. It was revealed last month that Barr has numerous troubling conflicts of interests in Russia. The guy is corrupt and bought:

https://www.newsweek.com/so-many-conflicts-so-little-time-1396435

reply

Do you think they'll impeach Barr?

reply

It is absolutely imperative Dems impeach Barr because he has indicated he is willing to flagrantly break the law to cover Trump's crimes. The sooner they figure out they don't have a choice, the better. Like I was saying to Rory above, the problem is this is the Democrats and they are just so weak and pathetic when it comes to these things that I give them a 50-50 shot of figuring out what to do before Trump runs out the clock.

Barr is ignoring House subpoenas and absolutely refusing to hand over the full un-redacted Mueller report. It'll require impeachment of either Trump or Barr to get that report. What is he so concerned about hiding that's in that report? Why has he been refusing to allow Mueller testify to the House? Obviously there's very politically damaging info he knows will be devastating to Trump or he wouldn't be flatly refusing to release the full report.

If Dems don't reign Barr in he WILL secretly obstruct all those cases Mueller passed off to SDNY prosecutors investigating the Trump crime family and snuff them out one by one. This is certain. He will prosecute Trump's political enemies like we'd expect to see in a 3rd world banana republic. Did you see that question by Harris yesterday asking him if the president ever asked him to open investigations into his political enemies and he stuttered and said he didn't know? Also expect to see him seek to get the Russians involved in compromising 2020, I have absolutely no doubt. The guy is evil to the core.

reply

See, this is why I never listened to all those people who thought my wife and I were crazy for accelerating her naturalization plans when Trump was elected. They all said we were overreacting, "oh, she'll be fine!" etc. We ignored all of them and spent an a$$load of money to get her US citizenship last year.

Why did we accelerate our plans? Because we saw the writing on the wall regarding how batsh!t insane Trump is. I am fully convinced that he might just be crazy enough to actually go through with shutting down our southern borders and maybe even suspend immigration entirely. I fully believe he's evil and crazy enough to even try to deport all immigrants one day.

Those people who told us not to worry back then don't know what they hell they were talking about. People used to scoff at Donald shutting the government down for an extended period and yet--he did it...and set the largest record ever for it...and even contemplated doing it again. He proved right then and there just HOW far he's willing to go in his insane conquest.

I leave nothing to chance anymore. I personally believe there is no limit to how far Donald might go if he can circumvent enough laws and agencies to do so. I'm actually shocked beyond belief he still hasn't had the DACA people tossed out.

Never in my entire LIFE have a feared one of our presidents before Trump came along. NEVER. My wife and I spent money we didn't have at the time to accelerate her naturalization and we have ZERO regrets about it to this day. Donald is unhinged and apparently unanswerable for his illegal actions. God only knows what will happen next.

reply

Maxine Waters tells Barr to resign or get ready for impeachment.

Get ready to ruuuumble!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

https://www.politicususa.com/2019/04/30/maxine-waters-tells-bill-barr-to-resign-or-get-ready-for-impeachment.html

reply

An attorney general being impeached...my, the times we're living in.

And here I thought the AG was supposed to be on my side. *Smacks head* Silly me!

reply

I'm at a point now where all I care about is one thing: Is this bad for Trump?

None of this is shocking and I expected all of it (as we all basically did). Watching Barr undermine Mueller like this to protect Trump is like the fulfillment of prophecy at this point: we all knew it was coming.

All I care about anymore is one thing: Could this lead to Trump's removal/resignation? Nothing else matters at this point.

reply

It's all riding on Mueller's testimony before congress. If the revelations from the full and unredacted Mueller Report are going to move mountains, that will be THE monumental event that sets the ball in motion.

Barr's DOJ was obstructing and stalling scheduling his testimony before the House for the past month, that's why his interview hadn't been scheduled. They only finally agreed today to have Mueller testify before the committee.

Bill Barr just keeps digging his hole deeper in these hearings today and I love it. He's now trying to blame all the delays releasing the report on Mueller.

I'm sure Mueller won't be happy about being scapegoated by Barr and will have something to say about that.

reply

See, I thought we've already had two years of mountain-moving going on here and yet that orange bastard remains untouched.

Can you provide some examples? I'm not doubting you but I'm at a point now where I'm absolutely shocked this guy hasn't already been punished for all the sh!t he's done. Obama would have already been out on his a$$ by now if he'd done even a QUARTER of what Donald has done.

reply

What if we learn in Mueller's testimony that Barr improperly ordered him to shut down the probe?

Remember last month when we were speculating how it was just way too fishy that Barr gets the job and suddenly the investigation shuts down with all these hanging threads?

It made absolutely no sense he didn't charge Don Jr for the exact same crime of lying to congress Cohen committed and was indicted over. Or that Corsi didn't get charged seeing as how they told him if he didn't sign the formal plea they were going to charge him. WTF? Or that Jared somehow escaped indictment?

What if we learn from Mueller he had intended to indict Don Jr, Jared, and Ivanka and Barr ordered him not to?

That would be explosive since it would be nothing short of criminal obstruction by Barr.

reply

Oh, I believe it. Before Barr lumbered on in, we kept hearing that Mueller's investigation was getting ready to indict new people--that he was asking for extensions to continue through May-June and blah blah blah...then Barr is appointed and BOOM. The entire thing just...ends.

We all have at least a basic idea of what must have gone on behind the scenes and EVERYONE knows--even the Trumpers. It's do damn painfully obvious that Barr shut the thing down swiftly.

And now we're learning that Mueller is, in fact, p!ssed with Barr and has, as Mueller's people already stated, misrepresented the findings of the investigation.

What gets me is that this isn't even shady--it's literally in our faces. It's TOO obvious--like something you'd see in a bad political movie.

What also bothers me is that Trumpers aren't bothered by this in the slightest. They're treating this like a "war" where they're reasoning it all away as: "Dems are doing it so we're gonna do it, too!" and that's it. Defending crime by condemning crime. Literally makes no sense and is a self-destructive mentality.

We're screwed as a nation. I really believe so. We've never been this divided.

reply

You're not wrong. Yesterday’s performance is a harbinger of escalating assaults on the rule of law we will see unfold over the next 20 months and quite possibly, depending on the results of 2020 election, for years to come. An article last night in the Times gives us a first look at what will make everything we’ve seen in the last 30 months seem quaint by comparison. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/01/us/politics/biden-son-ukraine.html

In summary, during the late Obama administration Joe Biden was the point man on pushing anti-corruption efforts in Ukraine. Part of that focused on ousting a corrupt chief prosecutor. Among the many companies the prosecutor was investigating was one that had a relationship with Biden's son, Hunter. The appearance of conflict of interest worried State Department officials at the time, however the prosecutor eventually was booted and the new guy dropped that and many other probes.

Fast forward to today. Giuliani, who has replaced Michael Cohen as Trump’s personal fixer/lawyer, has been meeting with Ukrainian officials repeatedly and dangling the possibility of better US relations if they will reopen the investigation into the Hunter Biden-affiliated company. In other words, the President’s personal lawyer is going abroad and using the lure of better treatment from the US prez to get them to reopen an investigation that could damage the man who is possibly Trump’s presidential competitor next year.

That’s not all.

Giuliani and Trump have asked Bill Barr to get the material Ukrainian prosecutors have assembled and start his own investigation in the US. So Giuliani starts meeting with Ukrainian officials who are for reasons we all understand desperate for favorable treatment from President Trump. He tells them that the way to get better treatment is to start an investigation into Joe Biden’s son.

reply

I don't think we need to assume that Hunter Biden is the cleanest guy in the world. What we do know is that lots of Americans were making money in semi-lawless Ukraine over the last decade but the idea that Biden was doing anything to help his son seems extremely strained. But the scary point is the President's private lawyer, unbound by any government regulation or responsibilities, is practicing unauthorized foreign policy on the President's behalf, the goal of which is to use the President's power to get other countries to attack his political enemies at home. Both Trump and Giuliani are then asking Bill Barr to open companion investigations targeting Trump's political enemies.

This is how corrupt, broken states operate, banana republics. Everything we've seen from Bill Barr tells us he will happily participate in this kind of corruption. Meanwhile, Giuliani spends lots of his time visiting foreign capitals in the last 18 months, ostensibly on private business. We have almost no visibility into what most of those visits are about. This is one example. What other stuff don't we know about?

We hear a lot about the next time foreign corruption or interference gets tied up in US elections, guarding against Russian meddling, hacking of elections, whatever. Pretty clearly it's already happening. Bill Barr's handling of the Mueller Report is getting all the attention. We're only learning some of the details now. But Mueller is hardly the only thing Barr's working on. He was unable or unwilling to answer yesterday whether the President or other White House officials had asked him to open other investigations. Sounds like Trump and Giuliani have already pressed him to get on this. No surprise. He's already begun his own personal investigations into the people who started the counterintel investigation into Trump. Barr is happy to relive his glory days as GOP cover-up operative of yore.

reply

Wow...this is scary.

I used to scoff at the notion of a Donald Trump dictatorship every coming to be, but...in some ways...I think it just might. He has managed to play and circumvent the entire system and skate out clean every time. He is wriggling out of every single legal situation with defiance and NO ONE stepping in to stop him. If no one is holding Trump accountable and if no one has the POWER to do anything about this corruption, then Trump is essentially above the law at this point. Dictators are above the law. He's trying and he's trying hard to get to that point.

That "Trump for dictator" crazy b!tch at the rally really riled me because she's echoing what most Trumpers honestly feel. You've seen them--Trumpers seem content with the idea of our country transforming into another North Korea.

Scary times...

reply

It could very well happen if Barr is not dealt with.

reply

"Could this lead to Trump's removal/resignation? Nothing else matters at this point."

Plenty of astute political analysis above that I won't repeat. Just watch and hang onto your seat. It's going to be really entertaining no matter what happens.

We just have to hope that as this scandal deepens and Mueller stands up for the cause of justice that it doesn't end in nuclear apocalypse. It's easy to see how the manchild might get it in his head that if he's going down, he's going to take the whole world with him.

reply

Scary to contemplate, but I think you may be right.

reply