MovieChat Forums > Politics > So what if Putin/Russia gets Ukraine?

So what if Putin/Russia gets Ukraine?


Or at least the part of the land bridge they fought for and won.

How is that going to affect you directly?

reply

America's real fight in this century is with China, and except for our insistence that no other country get rich and powerful enough to challenge us, China has not been near the hegemon the US has been.

Ukraine is a stupid diversion that we caused by insisting to pull all of Europe into NATO - against the USSR, which doesn't exist any more.

Yes, what about Putin? But most of Putin's support comes from his standing up to Western NATO expansion and our constant actions to undermine the Russian economy. A catch-22 caused the by the US. The main point of the war in Ukraine is to hobble the Russian economy - not in support of a now non-existent democracy in Ukraine. Putin will be out at some point probably soon, next 10-20 years. It would have been good if the US could have worked with Putin, as he is much smarter than all of our recent Presidents and has been engaged with this for 30+ years. Putin could have been persuaded to sensibly move Russia towards democracy with the right incentives.

John Mearsheimer, who I agree with on Ukraine but disagree with on Palestine, said that Russia is winning and will win the Ukraine war, taking in total 8 Ukrainian oblasts/states, and cutting Ukraine off from the sea, turning it into a useless rump state. As such, Europe and NATO will end up not wanting to even bother with Ukraine.

So effectively was we have done is to drive Russia towards China, destroy Ukraine, hurt Russia a little bit, but end up beefing up their military industrial complex, for the purposes of keeping Europe in our economic sphere. You can argue that either way if you don't care about killing tens of thousands of people and destroying one of the breadbaskets of the world for America's profit.

Republicans Bush and Trump were major actors in this. Bush pushing NATO expansion, and Trump being the first President to ship weapons to Ukraine. Democrats face their share of the blame for doing nothing to stop it or negotiate.

This is a good independent media discussion of the Ukraine situation from today:
Did the West Provoke Russia in Ukraine? Watch John Mearsheimer's Take on Moscow's War on Kyiv
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEwYCVJtKvs
Less than 1/2 hour

reply

Who is this Mearsheimer guy? Another crazy Qanon conspiracy theorist? No thanks. Dude - start thinking for yourself. Stop other people thinking for you. That's why people like you are called "victims of brainwashing propaganda".

It's so hard to have any conversation with brainwashed people.

That NATO nonsense was debunked millions times and years ago. Yet brainwashed people still repeat it like it's true. LOL.

No, Americas real fight in this century is not with China. It's nonsense that Trump and then his Qanons made up to avert from that fact he is russian loyal doggy and takes orders from putin like a little bitch. So he keeps and keeps trying to convince his stupid fanatics that China or Krakozia or Socovia are the real problem.

reply

When someone repeats word to word russian propaganda then they are not "independent media discussion". They are russian propagandists. LOL.

Your John Mearsheimer is an idiot and old fart who should move to home for elderly people, not discussing world politics he has no knowledge off.

I see pattern that many of those Qanon conspiracy idiots look at everything from "russian position" and then work as their apologists. If internet would exist during WW2 then we would see same idiots who would run around and scream that "poor hitler was forced to start ww2. He was tricked. He warned them all to ... something... but evil CIA, NATO, Martians, Cows did not listen! It's all over. He already took this and this country. Europe lost. USA should accept it and start working with nazi germany....". And other crap like that.

reply

That's a good point about the Internet during WWII.

reply

If Internet and Social Media would exist back then then 100% that nazi germans would act the same as nazi russians. Goebbels propaganda would claim that no one bombs other countries. There are no concentration camps, no ghettos. And it's all a lie, made up by American media and hitler haters. They would call them "naziphobes".

And Elon Masks of that time would sit all day and claim war is lost and Europe must surrender and stop losing people. Putting stupid memes about Winston Churchill. The one political party in USA who would not be in power and their candidate for presidency would attack party in power and claim "hitler is a good man". And their press and qanons would run around Internet and scream that USA must stop helping Europe and deal with American problems....

Humanity was very lucky that Internet did not exist during WW2.

reply

You're right humanity was lucky we didn't have internet back then & that's a horrifying realization considering where we are today.

reply

In the Ukraine, slavic people are much freer from other slavic people. In russia, slavic people are not free from psychopath slavs. In western civilization, being freer from psychopath people is sought after. So, if russia gets ukraine that means that in yet another country people are not free from the psychopaths of that country.

People who can feel real emotions, who are sane and psychopath people do not want psychopath people to have any power over them.

reply

The Russian Federation will likely declare war on Ukraine in a few days or weeks, I'm not sure, but when it happens, we will all know.

The west did really push Putin. If you live in Kiev, you want to leave as soon as it's announced.

reply

Dude I have a bad news for you. nazi russia declared full on war on Ukraine 2 years ago.

No one pushed putin. Only voiced in his crazy head.

Did west and martians pushed hitler too? LOL. Stop humiliating yourselves, trumpists. This is embarrassing.

And its Kyiv not Kiev you idiot.

reply

Ukraine is now a shithole.

Surrender to Russia to let them have it so their war destruction is Russia's problem instead and it will cease anymore civilians from being killed and they won't have to deal with such a corrupt country anymore.

This would be a win win win for Ukr.

Anyone who disagrees is a dumbass.

reply

Sure, Ivan. As you say. LOL.

Go get your 5 rubles from your nazi russia owners. Putin huilo. Death to nazi russia.

reply

Anyone who is against what I wrote is for more civilians being killed.

reply

Dude - you are nazi and terrorist supporter and apologist. You have no say in this. LOL.

Go home Ivan, there is no vodka here. And no toilets to steal.

reply

I'm on the side of anti war.

Get a clue you fucking idiotic troll.

reply

No, hon. You are on the side of terro-russia.

reply

If that's the crackpot bullshit you wanna make up then you just go on right ahead.

I'm done with you seeing how full of shit you are.

reply