MovieChat Forums > Aladdin (2019) Discussion > Why did Disney bother to remake Aladdin ...

Why did Disney bother to remake Aladdin in a live action version?


I saw the first few minutes of the live action Aladdin on Disney+ and I can say it is the worst Disney movie in history. Take for instance why did Will Smith start out as a mariner when he tells the story of Aladdin to two little kids? Because in the animated version the song Arabian Nights starts the film and then the peddler tells the story of Aladdin but in this version Will Smith's Arabian Nights doesn't hold a candle to the late Bruce Adler's original version. Second I felt that the movie was rushed and that some scenes were missing that should've been there. Like when Aladdin sang One Jump Ahead they changed the lyrics and then in the animated version Aladdin and Abu share a feast of a loaf of bread but they didn't have that scene in this Aladdin. Instead Aladdin follows a woman who is not Jasmine but someone named Dalia now where Dalia came from I have no idea. Now in the animated version Aladdin made his home on the roof of a building but in this version Aladdin's home is a minaret like the type of towers they have in the Middle Eastern countries and Aladdin's room is decorated with furniture straight out of Pier 1 Imports and Disney could've done a better job designing this room. Onto the animals why did they make Abu so creepy looking and weird? I thought the animated Abu was cute and they should made Abu cute rather than weird. But I do like Rajah in this movie because he looks handsome and I love tigers. But I think Disney should've been smart and gone back to the drawing board and studied the animated version of Aladdin first before making this version. Hopefully the live action Mulan will be better than this movie

reply

Why shouldn't Will Smith start out as the mariner? And he still sang Arabian Nights at the beginning of the film.

How was the movie rushed?! It's over 2 hours long whereas the original was barely an hour an 20 minutes.

Why is it important to have the scene where both Aladdin and Abu feast on the a loaf of bread? What is the significance of it that was vital to have in this version?

Aladdin didn't follow Dalia, he didn't follow anyone. He MET Jasmine. Jasmine later on told him her name was Dalia, after her hand maiden, to hide her identity. How did you miss that?

Raja is a girl.


These live-action versions of the originals aren't always gonna follow the originals scene-by-scene. It makes better sense to add things or go a slightly different way to jazz it up a bit. That way we fans can enjoy the nostalgia of our childhood movies whilst enjoying a movie that could be special movie in its own right. These movies are more adaptations rather than exact replicas. I honestly dont think they'd get as much of a following if they kept it exactly the same.

If I'm honest, I think you're nit-picking a little bit. I think the magic of turning a beloved Disney cartoon into live-action may be lost on you.

Personally, I'm not a massive fan of the original (despite the fact I've seen it so many times 😆). I have only just now watched this version, almost a year since it's release, but I was impressed by it.
Just let the magic be what it is.

reply

Hopefully the live action Mulan will be better than this movie


Ha.

reply

money

reply