MovieChat Forums > Timeless (2016) Discussion > Lindbergh was not from St. Louis

Lindbergh was not from St. Louis


Lazy writing with Baker saying Lindy was from St. Louis. His plane was called the Spirit of St. Louis because his investors were from St. Louis.
This is a poorly written show on every level.

reply

He was originally from Minnesota and his dad's congressional seat was from Minnesota. He was, however, a member of the Missouri Air National Guard when he made his transatlantic flight.

reply

...named the "Spirit of St. Louis" in honor of Lindbergh's supporters from the St. Louis Raquette Club in his then hometown of St. Louis, Missouri.



Hate-watching says more about the viewer than it does about the show.

reply

I don't watch this show but I know of many of it's poor qualities because my wife watches it and asks me questions. You probably didn't consider options.



Hate-posting says more about the respondent than it does about the original comment.

reply

Hate-posting says more about the respondent than it does about the original comment.


A_Real_Hip_Dude, my post was in response to MadTom's - not to the OP's.

There was nothing 'hateful' about it.

Just facts.

And apparently your wife has better taste in tv shows than she does in men.  


Hate-watching says more about the viewer than it does about the show.

reply

I know who you were responding to, I never said the original poster. But you were being an antagonstic smart ass, all the same.

And I think it's aafe to say thia was a hate-post from you, so it all came around anyway.





Liberals claim to love "others ideas", until they find out people actually have other ideas.

reply

"blah, blah, blah'
Dude, I don't care.

These boards are closing in ten days because of goofs like you.

Buzz off - go bug your wife.

She has to put with your sh!t - I don't.

Hate-watching says more about the viewer than it does about the show.

reply

You don't list the source of your quote, but whatever the source is, it is incorrect. Lindbergh was not from St. Louis. Lindbergh was from Little Falls, Minnesota. As an adult, he bounced around the mid-west working as a pilot in Wisconsin, Nebraska, Illinois, and Missouri. He lived in St. Louis for less than two years in the mid-1920s. That hardly qualifies as a hometown by any definition.

reply

Lindbergh was from Little Falls, Minnesota.

WRONG

Charles Augustus Lindbergh was born on Feb. 4, 1902, in Detroit.
Here's your source - you can stick where the sun don't shine.
http://www.charleslindbergh.com/history/


Ha! So both you and the show are WRONG.

I love it.


Hate-watching says more about the viewer than it does about the show.

reply

And keep in mind, everyone, purediesel feels authorized to declare others as the reason why the message boards are shutting down.





Liberals claim to love "others ideas", until they find out people actually have other ideas.

reply

Born in, not from. You're from where you grew up, not where you popped out.

And hey, if you weren't cherry picking like a fake news source, you wouldn't have left off the next line...

Charles Augustus Lindbergh was born on Feb. 4, 1902, in Detroit. He grew up on a farm near Little Falls, Minn.


He was from Minnesota, even if he was born in Detroit.

--
You have many question, Mr Sparkle. I send you premium -- answer question, hundred percent!

reply

No such thing as "his then hometown." (sic)

One's hometown is where one was born. So unless this show alters the timeline to have him born somewhere else, his "hometown" will always be Detroit, MI.

..Joe

reply

I'm not sure that Lindbergh was as bad a person as Lucy makes him out to be either. Considering the way the First World War turned out, was wanting to keep America out of the next world war such a bad thing? Ok, so maybe events proved Lindbergh wrong but he did redeem himself by fighting as a civilian when he couldn't get into uniform.

reply

rtlh1982,

Thank you. So you also noticed they kind of unfairly trashed the guy, right? They made it sound like the Nazis gave the guy a medal later during the war because he supported them and acted on it. Am I right?

I started a thread on this but got mostly trashed for it. Sorry, but most of this show's episodes the writers are guilty of presentism and have a liberal biased of 2017. I am glad at least other people here see this.

reply

You were trashed because your comments were stupid. Whether they were overtly harsh on Lindberg's legacy is a matter of opinion, it certainly wasn't extreme, as you tried to make it out to be. You were saying everyone wanted to kill him because of his latter isolationists and anti-semantic stance. The only character that wanted to kill him was the bad guy on the show and that was because of Rittenhouse. Your attempt to turn it into some sort of liberal bias agenda just doesn't hold water. This is a badly written show. In regard to historical accuracy, it has none. They have been very consistent in their inaccuracy. It isn't due to any sort of agenda, it's bad and lazy writing.

reply

"Your attempt to turn it into some sort of liberal bias agenda just doesn't hold water."

Why the fuck do you feel the need to involve politics in this?

reply

obviously something changed in the past that resulted in Lindbergh being from St Louis in this timeline /s

reply

Yep. I lost interest in the first episode.

reply