MovieChat Forums > Hell or High Water (2016) Discussion > Is this film a satire or are Texans real...

Is this film a satire or are Texans really like this?


Is Texan culture really so gun-obsessed?

reply

what is your problem? nuu yarker or did you watch last 20 minutes 10 times or what?

_______
"if seagal was thinner this could have been a theatrical product."

reply

[deleted]

What DO Texans need to carry guns for??? What is this, the wild west of the 1800s?

reply

[deleted]

Lots of concealed carry here. And the occasional open carry folks with loaded rifles - but they're not gathering as much as they were when mass shootings renewed the gun debate 2015-2016.

And no, it's not the wild west.

Not a native Texan, but been here most of my life.

reply

Because I can't carry a cop in my back pocket.

reply

I think the whole of America seems gun-obsessed.

reply

Nahhhhhhhhhh

reply

Freedom obsessed.

reply

When I visited Dallas, only saw the Dallas Police Dept with guns on view. Saw lots of stetsons and cowboy boots, and huge belt buckles.

reply

You must have been in Fort Worth. You would be hard pressed to see people like you are describing in Dallas. I'm a Dallas native.

reply

My guess is not as much as south and west Chicagoland, but close.

reply

Texans need lots of guns to compensate for their tiny peckers.

Also to make sure they get killed instead of just robbed, should they ever meet armed criminals.

- Say, that's actually not so bad, is it?


reply

Interesting that you mention "Chicagoland" which you likely have never even been to, as that's just a CITY not an entire state. I can easily picture the ancestors of modern-day Texans in the backwoods of Europe, with the same superstitious mentality and fear of foreigners that their descendants have today. 

reply

Nah it's not that bad people like guns but the idea of a bunch of townies chasing armed bank robbers down a highway was ridiculous. That would be like making a movie about Harlem and literally every person walking down the sidewalk was smoking weed. I'm sure people in Harlem like smoking weied but not every single person living there..

reply

It's a caricature for sure. What you get when you have a British guy direct a film about crime in the American south.

reply

Well it's not a documentary. So there is some suspension of belief involved. Most movies aren't based in reality.

reply

Thus, my use of the word, caricature,.. not character. Nor documentary.

reply

There may be elements of overstatement in this film, which makes using the word caricature perhaps defensible up to a point. But neither is it fair and honest to contend the characters shown have no relation to the way people in that part of Texas really are. There's a lot of truth in the portrayals.

reply

[deleted]

The writer, Taylor Sheridan, is a native Texan. Family lost their ranch when he was young.

reply

Ohm, it's the wild, wild, west.

I think it's more like you have to walk in their shoes to get the gist of how it down them ways. What they have to contend with. Whom all else totes a gun? Why the need? From what? Whom? It's all relative.

GFW

reply