MovieChat Forums > The Perks of Being a Wallflower (2012) Discussion > Which Did You like better? This or Silve...

Which Did You like better? This or Silver Lining Play book, your age?

posted 11 years ago by jacobthecheeseburger
97 replies | jump to latest

Which Did You like better? This or Silver Lining Play book, and what is your age?

I feel that SLP was probly ten times better, and was much deeper and less pretensions, I LOVED perks of being a wall flower, but it was pretentious at times especially the scene where logan or ema are hanging out from the top of the car when it goes into the bridge, but pretinsiouness is not bad all the time and I really liked the movie, I would give "Perks" a A- and SLP a A+. Which did you think was better? Iv'e noticed the younger generation likes "perks" better(which is wierd cause i am the youger generation, im 15), some of my friends though SLP was stupid and thought perks was amazing, Here are my movie suggestions for 2012-
http://movieirony.weebly.com/2012.html

WHICH WAS BETTER?

I... Drink... Your... Milk Shake! - Daniel Plainview

[–] Mytochondriak 11 years ago

Silver Lining Playbook for me, I'm 37.

Funny I find this thread, these are the last 2 movies I watched.

Really enjoyed both though (the ending of perks is really nice when he's on the car in the tunnel, brought me a feeling of nostalgia), but preferred SLP.

[–] Abby_Absinthe 11 years ago

Perks. Silver linings wasn't bad but at times, it just seemed weird. I had a similiar high school experience as Charlie, so I guess it's just closer to my heart.

A few days away from being 20.

So glad to meet you, Angeles.

[–] saltcoatston 11 years ago

Perks 10/10
SLP 9/10

29 y.o. male

[–] neo_angin 11 years ago

Silver linings playbook 9/10
Perks of being wallflower 7/10

I'm 22.

[–] robeacero1 11 years ago

Perks, but I also like a lot SLP

[–] 11 years ago

[deleted]

[–] sadat23 10 years ago

This is my first reply to a thread on IMDB. I just finished watching The Perks of Being a Wallflower for the 3rd time and I still love this movie as much as I did watching it the first time. Watched Silver Linings Playbook twice and I think it's a good movie too but personally I liked The Perks of Being a Wallflower better. I am 24.

[–] 10 years ago

[deleted]