MovieChat Forums > 3 Body Problem (2024) Discussion > Plot inconsistencies that cannot be igno...

Plot inconsistencies that cannot be ignored. (Spoilers)


The plot of "The 3 Body Problem" is based on scientists being so confused and desperate at the chaotic results of new subatomic physics experiments that do not make sense or agree with old experiments that they decide to kill themselves. Pretty weak-willed scientists is what I think.

Inconsistencies are exactly what scientists mean to find in experiments - results that do not make sense that require new understanding. It would be like a puzzle, like when, whoever it was, Watson or Crick had the dream about the double-helix nature of DNA.

Science only advances with experiments that do not make sense or non-linearities where results that are not what are predicted - therein lies new areas to find out about, understand and exploit. In reality what would have happened is that scientists would communicate these bizarre results to other scientists, or publish them in the science journals and talk about them and discuss what could have produced such results.

They would go back and try to find the experiments that either would be consistent and build from there, or realize that there were some kind of outside force affecting their experiments and set about trying to make sense of it.

Also, I am not sure it really made any sense for the aliens to have contact with humans once they knew where we were and set their invasion fleet sailing. And in this version of the story, the aliens being confused by humans' ability to lie seemed silly.

And finally, any civilization that could unfold two protons in quantum entanglement, send them to Earth and manipulate many peoples' realities, and be in all places on the Earth at practically all times ... why would they not be able to solve their own problems by moving their planet out of the way, or steering their suns into a stable arrangement?

reply

They weren't suicides. Tatiana (or someone else) killed them.

reply

Nope, the suicides were all over the world of famous scientists.

reply

They were made to look like suicides

reply

No, you are just over-assuming that based on the murder of the super-rich guy.
They showed the daughter of [what's her name] deliberately falling to her death.

reply

Yeah, but that was suicide from guilt. She was manipulated the old fashioned way - by her loved one.

reply

I may be confusing the Chinese series ( which I think was better ) with the British one, but she wrote the same note.

reply

The last bit you mention, the apparent technological prowess of the civilization -- building some kind of multidimensional quantum computer, a fleet of generation ships, advanced AI, etc -- suggests there were a bunch of other possible alternatives for their civilization besides fleeing to Earth.

Which IMHO is part of the larger problem with interstellar aliens as a concept -- if they can conquer interstellar space travel spanning light years, what the heck is Earth to them anyway other than *maybe* a 7-11 stop for material resources they might find harder to grab elsewhere, and only this maybe if turns out that transmutation of elements even with limitless power sources isn't viable and the distribution of elements is wildly uneven on a galactic scale.

And if they possessed the power to basically achieve omniscience over Earth with their quantum multidimensional computer, aren't there 1001 ways they can fuck with Earth civilizations to ruin any chance of resistance? Only making scientists crazy and sabotaging their research seems like unnecessary stealth and complexity.

Haven't read the novel(s), but I feel like they somehow need Earth and its people for something and just letting us annihilate ourselves and letting Earth heal for 400 years isn't sufficient.

reply

Since I read the original book ... so long ago that I pretty much forgot it ... the author has come out with I think at least two sequels to "The Three Body Problem". I imagine this series will to do a follow-on. I really did not think this was that great and I was waiting for it for a long time thinking it would be really good.

reply