MovieChat Forums > Wicked: Part One (2024) Discussion > Seems like they intentionally downplaye...

Seems like they intentionally downplayed the fact it's a musical


Very little to indicate this is a musical. Maybe they don't think it will have as broad of appeal?

reply

Musicals are an acquired taste. I was excited watching the Super Bowl trailer until I found out it was a musical. Now I’m just meh. Hopefully it’s not too much music and just an actual film.

reply

My wife loves the stage version, but filmed musicals don't exactly draw either of us in.

reply

Movie musicals used to be better than the stage versions.

reply

Yup, they made some amazing adaptations. Seems like the slump started in the 90s.

reply

I would say more like in the 1970s. There’s Man of La Mancha and The Wiz.

reply

There were some great Broadway adaptations in the 80s, but looking back, they were all early 80s. Annie, Best Little Whorehouse, Little Shop of Horrors...man, these were great. And there were originals too, luke Popeye, that were a lot of fun. The recent Wonka had a reminiscent vibe to that time. I really enjoyed it.

reply

Right, I wasn’t saying they were all bad, just that it started a little sooner than you said. I love Little Shop of Horrors. I started getting into that one after one of my best friends played Audrey II in an onstage production of it.

reply

despite going to public school, I had a very religious drama teacher who wouldn't do anything she deemed inappropriate. Man eating plant wouldn't have been ok. She wouldn't even let us do Grease,lol.

reply

I remember reading the stage musical script for Grease, and it had surprisingly a ton of swearing and F bombs.

With that said, I do think the movie is way better than the stage show.

reply

Her biggest issue was the idea that the innocent girl turned to bad behavior to get the boy.

reply

Yes, she is not the only one to hate that ending. Lots of people did, including fans of the movie Grease.

My biggest issue is certain iconic songs are missing, most notably “Hopelessly Devoted to You” and “You're the One that I Want”. The latter had this other song called “I’m All Shook Up” in its place in the stage show and man it suuuuuucks.

reply

I didn't know the ending was controversial back in the day. I was 2 when the movie came out, so not on my radar, lol.

reply

I don’t know about controversial, I’m just saying I’ve heard lots of people say the same thing you did.

reply

I'm surprised, those chicks are the best!

reply

The studio is probably worried it's going to bomb so they're hiding the fact it's a musical.

reply

Wonka dud pretty decent, but musicals have a bad track record lately. They might becright to be concerned, but then why make it.

reply

Wonka is also a prequel to a film that is also a musical

reply

If anyone doesn’t know that this is a musical, I can’t help them.

reply