MovieChat Forums > Another Gay Movie (2007) Discussion > Some scenes were in extremely poor taste

Some scenes were in extremely poor taste


Having just recently viewed "Another Gay Movie" on video,' I must admit the film did succeed as a comic spoof on the heterosexual teen sex movie genre, e.g., "American Pie," "Porky's," "Fast Times at Ridgemont High," etc. Generally speaking, most of the move depicted a similar brand of crude and raunchy sexual humor that it's hetero counterparts are well-known for.

However, the director noted in the film's commentary that some viewers (gay and straight) were offended by many aspects of the film. The director defended the controversial content in the name of "pushing artistic boundaries and leaving political correctness at the door."

Well, I also took offense to some scenes and would challenge the director's lame defense for several reasons. But first, let me identify some offending scenes:

1. The scene in the gay bar where the two old men ask the Griff character his age and state that he was way passed his prime age at 17 (a clear reference to pedophilia).

2. The scene where Andy's father reveals that he's bisexual and then proceeds to pursue a man into public restroom for sex.

3. The sex scene between the Andy character and his teacher.

The reason such scenes are offensive is partly because they appeal to the harmful characterization that homosexuals are perverse and behave without any boundaries of decency. Furthermore, the message such scenes send is that everything in the pursuit of gay sexual fulfillment is fine. No action or behavior is ever wrong or inappropriate when it comes to gay sex.

Too often in the name of "pushing the artistic envelop" gay directors make the mistake of communicating that any and every behavior as acceptable. But I would argue that there is nothing even remotely funny about suggesting that gay individuals condone pedophilia, that it's ok for a gay teacher to have sex with a teenager or that it's acceptable for a married man, in the pursuit of sexual freedom, to cheat on his wife -- right in from of his own son no less.

Exploiting such behavior for mere laughs ignores the damage such images do to the larger depiction of gay individuals in society by perpetuating these vile and harmful stereotypes. It's bad enough that there is a hateful anti-gay crowd that already equates homosexually with the most base human behavior imaginable. Gay directors and writers should be the last people to validate such prejudiced and homophobic beliefs.


reply

Some of the scenes like NAMBLA and the hamster thing have already been done in SouthPark episodes. If you find South Park offending, then this movie not for you.

reply

Am I the only one who knew and understood that this movie was suppose to be a gay spoof on a teen comedy?

Has anybody seen a teen comedy before??

I mean there's things to complain about and take a stand against but good lord give it a rest.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

The scene with the hamster in the kitchen made me feel so uncomfortable!

reply

Yeah I think the hamster was the worst, and puts gays in really bad light. Funny? Kinda, but not really. At least on South Park it was funny. I would hate for anyone to think gay people put hamsters in their asses. Sick!

reply

In South Park they had Chef on hand to contextualise:

"Children- there is a difference between gay people, and Mr Garrison"

reply

You know... I understand that the acceptability of those scenes was very low, but you have to view them from a comedic standpoint. They were meant for humor, not to offend or to disgust. The NAMBLA scene, I thought, was hysterical, and I was raped as a fifteen year old. So don't buy or rent a comedy movie, if you're not ready for all kinds of comedy.

reply

If it was a straight teen movie and a straight teen had discovered that his female teacher was a dominatrix or something, it wouldn't be complained about, so get over it. I'm gay by the way.

You know me...bright ideas just pop into me head, and I keep thinking...

reply

I didn't bother to read much of the previous posts, but this is for the TC.

*beep* you and your 'politically correct' mindset. if you don't like it, turn the damn movie off.

That is all.

"Stupid Banana-Raincoat-Wearin' B****."

reply

This movie is a spoof of the teen movie genre & like South Park is a SATIRE. It's not making fun of gay people, it's making fun of stereotypes of gay people!! If you want to watch a really stupid, pointless movie--rent the sequel, it's pretty awful by comparison!

reply

Oh Mary! Get over it. It's just a spoof of teen and gay movies. It's meant to explode stereotypes by cramming them all into the movie and exaggerating them.

reply

The fact remains that some older gay men do chase after young boys (16+), just like some straight men lust after school girls. you guys have school girl pornos for god's sake! it's just the same!

reply

This movie is a comedy, not a documentary.

reply