MovieChat Forums > Three (2006) Discussion > Where is the uproar over this 'rape' sce...

Where is the uproar over this 'rape' scene?


How come over on Straw Dogs, the orginal, there's so much uproar over a similar rape scene where the girl goes "No! No!" yet ends up enjoying it but there are no threads here with the same angry responses?

reply

It's pretty obvious that Jennifer was a whore who wanted Manuel's cock inside her. That's all.
Hama cheez ba-Beer behtar meshawad!

reply

Is every woman a whore just because she wants sex? Are you straight?

reply

shes a whore not for wanting to have sex, but actually for having sex with him. It doesnt matter if her husband was a dick, she was always saying she loved him and got really happy when Manuel found him. And then she was playing the victim just because Jack didnt want to share anything with them. Why would he tho? She cheated on him lol #teamjack

reply

My post is a reply to zoltan-jose's post of Sat Apr 20 2013 12:11

reply

I soooo agree with you anny! It was one of those "Stop stop...don't stop" things. She was still a whore.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I don't think anyone takes this movie seriously enough to even give it credit for being incredibly dumb & offensive.

reply

[deleted]

It wasn't rape. It started out as a fight that turned into mutual sex. They both reacted at the same time and got into it. I guess you could call it angry sex. One minute you're fighting with someone, the next your going at it.

The rape scene in Straw Dogs was very different. It started out as rape, then became reluctant sex, and then mutual sex, the rape again.

reply

Manuel only lasted 36 seconds, so is that even long enough to be considered sex?

reply

They were fighting, then started kissing during the struggle. Both very into it...then...they had sex. There was never a "no" by her in any way vocally or otherwise. How is that considered rape?

reply

[deleted]

Ummmm...yes, here clearly WAS a "no" by her...both specifically her saying now, and her actions and mannerisms.

Please never be around human beings if you don't see that.

reply

I am in an uproar that someone compared Straw Dogs to this pile of dung.

reply

Watching Kelly Brook getting raped on the beach is an incredibly hot and sexy scene to watch. Yes, it is similar to the rape scene in Straw Dogs, but which movie has the sexiest rape scene? Basic Instinct? Lady of The Night?

reply

This "movie" doesn't deserve any comment let alone an uproar it is so mediocre and boring.

reply

I disagree. I got two-2-two copies & I ain't giving up either one.

reply