MovieChat Forums > One Tree Hill (2003) Discussion > Who's the hottest girl on the show?

Who's the hottest girl on the show?

posted 2 years ago by jasonbayly13181 (177)
6 replies | jump to latest

I can't decide between Brooke and Quinn. Both total smoke shows. Different personalities and have very different looks from one another, but both so hot!

[–] Mustang (5257) 2 years ago

Haley for me but I like the girl next door look.

Between Brooke and Quinn I would choose Quinn.

[–] Mustang (5257) 6 months ago

Watching it again of the 3 main female leads,

Best body - Brooke
Prettiest face - Peyton
Girl next door - Haley

Overall hottest - Taylor
Runner up - The clean teen leader Shelley
Best legs - Brooke & Quinn for the tie

Most over rated - Alex.
Would have liked to see more of - Lindsay

[–] blue1981 (6615) 6 months ago

My favorites in no particular order.

Jana Kramer(Alex)
Shantel Vansaten(Quinn)
Torrey Devito (Nanny Carrie)

[–] Mustang (5257) 6 months ago

I was surprised when I heard Jana sing. She was better than the rather un attractive Mia that they keep pushing throughout the series.

[–] blue1981 (6615) 6 months ago

I thought Katie Voegele is very pretty plus she has bigger boobs which I always like.

[–] Mustang (5257) 6 months ago

I noticed you have a type from your selection above. Asides from Shantel I found Torrey and Jana too thin. For some reason I liked Peyton even though she is very thin too.