MovieChat Forums > The Man Who Wasn't There (2001) Discussion > Top 5 black and white US films since 197...

Top 5 black and white US films since 1970.


The previous thread on this topic was fascinating but a bit vague.

1) Schindler's List
2) The Man Who Wasn't There
3) Ed Wood
4) Clerks *
5) The Addiction *

* I'm open to ideas on these last two and know that technically "Raging Bull" & "The Last Picture Show" trump them both - but I just "respected" Bull & Picture Show more than I actually "enjoyed" them.


If only you could see what I have seen through your eyes.

reply

Clerks is one the the worst movies of all time. Horribly acted, written, directed... And totally unfunny.

reply

In no particular order:

Frances Ha
Schindler's List
Manhattan
Dead Man
Elephant Man

reply

Thank you for remembering Manhattan. That's one of the finest films ever committed to celluloid - B&W or colour.

reply

Sin city
Young Frankenstein
Clerks

Uva Uvam Vivendo Varia Fit

reply

If you allow Schindler's List and Raging Bull, these would be my top 2, but both did involve some color, even if only a tiny moment.

If not, my top 5 are:
The Elephant Man
Good Night, and Good Luck
Following
Pi
Down by Law

Top 5 foreign B&W:
The White Ribbon
Man Bites Dog
La Haine
Werckmeister Harmonies
The Artist

reply

The Artist
The Man Who Wasn't There
Nebraska
The Elephant Man
Raging Bull - tied with - Ed Wood

Pretty standard list I guess.

I'm going to find it and I'm going to destroy it. I don't know how yet. Possibly with dynamite.

reply

1) Schindler's List
2) Wings Of Desire
3) Clerks
4) The Man Who Wasn't There
5) (tie) Lenny / Natural Born Killers

reply

Wings Of Desire. Great call !

reply

1) Paper Moon
2) Schindler's List
3) The Man Who Wasn't There
4) Nebraska
5) Ed Wood

reply

Of the B&W movies I can think of right at the moment (in alphabetical order):

The Last Picture Show
Manhattan
The Man Who Wasn't There
Paper Moon
Young Frankenstein

reply

I really like Last Picture Show, more so than the other movies mentioned here. It's somber yet lively in some ways (Cybill Shepherd), the young men are suitably confused, Cloris is heart-breaking, and good ol' Ben Johnson. Great cinematography, great setting.

reply