What if Ray accepted the trip offer


Will wouldnt be able to go with them...

reply

He did. On his way Ben ran him off the road forcing him to the hospital.

reply

Even if Ray did accept the trip was a fake anyway (I think?) and Will would have found his way there somehow with his dear ol' dad in tow. He was going to surprise Julie. Ray was going to be there no matter what.

reply

That did just make me think of something else though.

Obviously they wanted Ray there.

And if Ray had gotten there in time to join the others, Will still would've had another way there. But they wanted Will with the group presumably to make it easier to track their movements as well as toy with Julie's emotions more first.

However. After running Ray off the road, it would've been smarter for Ben to take Ray with him if they wanted him there. Because I'm guessing Ben got there by boat. And he had the time, since it's stated that Ray was found alone. It would've ensured Ray's presence, and they would've had him as prisoner. Sure, Ray got there, and had the will to do so, but it was dumb of them to rely on that, a number of things could've gone wrong with Ray getting himself there. And it would've deprived him of medical care. Really the only benefit to the way they did it was Ray tiring himself out en route, but that clearly did no good.

reply

Don’t forget he still knows

reply

Now I'm actually wondering what their whole plan was with Ray. It seems strange they would want to kill him so early on, instead of getting him to the island and play a cat-and-mouse game with him.

reply

Sooo...there was an extra plane ticket unsused and they would have put 3 in one room?

reply

The real question is, what if Carla decided to take someone else besides Julie.



Stalked by coleburnz07 since 2012 and Scarletknights since 2007!

reply

It would have been less contrived if he had gone. Don't get me wrong I *beep* love I Still Know What You Did Last Summer but Ray has always been a bane of contention with this film.

What it needed was a way for all of them to go on holiday without contriving the plot, at my university there were often events organised such as holiday's that you had to write your name down for. It would have been far easier for them all to put their names down to go on the holiday then it was to win a competition.

Generally they all just had to go on holiday, further to this a bigger cast would have served the film well because if there is one thing that kills a slasher movie fast it's a low body count.

reply

If Ray had gone with them in the first place there wouldn't of been a gun to shoot out Ben Willis. They would had to fight Will and Ben off some other way, or be killed.

reply

So your telling me that after the events of the first film neither had a gun on them? It is just a film, it would have made sense for either of them to have one. The scene on the plane would have been awkward what with customs and all but even that could have been explained, just go by boat. Also Ben manages to kill with a hook on his hand, a bit of brute force could have got the job done a gun is just quicker, Julie had an axe at one point, look at Jamie Leigh at the end of Halloween: H20 a axe got the job done.

reply

Its like Freddie wasn't able to be in the movie for long, like they pushed him in just to bring a familiar face that was popular, after all Helen and Barry were dead. He got on my nerves and was so hlingy getting angry because Julie didn't want to go back to the town all that tragedy happened in. I hoped he would get killed in the end and have Julie and Carla live.

reply

Yeah, but if they'd done it that way, Ben would've had to just kind of hang around and wait and hope that at some point they'd go on vacation and he'd magically have a way to learn their travel info. Plus, then he wouldn't have had control over when and where they went, both of which were of the utmost importance.

reply