MovieChat Forums > Jackie Brown (1997) Discussion > Anyone else thinks it iss overrated?

Anyone else thinks it iss overrated?


It is a common piece that you can see on TV anytime. 3 of 5 stars.

reply

Yes, just watched it and it didn't do much for me. The plot was interesting but I just didn't care about any of the characters. DeNiro was pretty good, or at least, I thought the scene where he showed his true colours when he shot Melanie was shocking, which made it good. SLJ was a bit of a cartoon character for me. I did hate him and I was glad when he was killed but it was too quick and easy for my liking. I'd have liked to see that evil git suffer a bit. I liked Max but the part was played in such a low key way, I half expected him to double cross Jackie in the end. And I can't buy Keaton as a tough guy, no matter what he is in.

That brings me to Pam Grier. I can't help but think that the only reason she was chosen for this film was because of her iconic past. I didn't mind her, but I never really liked her. Sure, SLJ's character deserved to be double crossed and killed, but was Melanie just collateral damage? Jackie might not have known SLJ would kill Melanie but she sure as hell knew how mistrustful he was of everyone, so she must have known it was likely.

When Jackie walks away at the end with the money, after causing the deaths (directly or indirectly) of three people, and putting the life of a decent man (Cherry) at risk, how is she any better, morally, than SLJ's character? Then, to top it all, she chose the money over love. I really struggled to find anything to redeem her character, or make me care whether she 'won' in the end.

reply

Definition of a troll:

He who posts something provocative to initiate discussion, then takes no further part in said discussion.

By the way, this story is not 'common'. Think of it as 'classical'.




Never defend crap with "It's just a movie"
http://www.youtube.com/user/BigGreenProds

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Absolutely Not!

I'll join the chorus of commentators who LOVE this movie. I just watched this again last night - it must be the fifth time I've seen it - and it's masterful. The casting was spot on, the pacing was excellent, the dialog was so natural and engaging I found myself rewinding it in multiple places just to hear the words repeated. And the music - Spectacular!

It's sad that so many people don't seem to want to appreciate all the subtleties of so many great movies.

reply

underrated. And i hope QT makes another movie like this one.

reply

I disagree. If this is a common piece that you see on TV any time, do you care with giving me so of those common any time examples, so I could watch them?

reply

I enjoyed the film. I wouldn't say it's QT's best but still a good film that would be great except for the running time. 3hrs is a bit indulgent if you ask me. it' came across as QT'S tribute to Pam Grier

"My Uncle still has MY nose...."

reply

I hear a lot of people say it's QT's best. It's a great film but I do think it drags in some parts. The acting and direction is amazing as always in every Tarantino flick but as for execution and action, there really isn't much of it. I feel Tarantino's trademark dialogue is missing and the film could have easily been at least 2 hours instead of 2 and a half. Just how I've always felt. Solid movie and definitely his most mature.


"Say What one more goddamn time!"

reply

it may not have the cool style that quentin is known for but it is still good

reply