Tombstone or Wyatt Earp?

My opinion is that, Tombstone was better. I prefer Kirk Russell as Wyatt, Sam Elliot as Virgil, Val Kilmer as Doc, and Bill Paxton as Morgan. I think maybe Wyatt Earp could have been a better historical account, but Tombstone was just put together better and had better acting. I mean really, Kilmer owned it as Holliday I thought. Quaid, not so much...

What do others think?