MovieChat Forums > Forrest Gump (1994) Discussion > Forrest Gump ~ Lost in Adaptation

Forrest Gump ~ Lost in Adaptation


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kO5dV6zg0Wk

Forrest Gump was based on a novel by Winston Groom, but how closely did they stick to it?

reply

The book is too politically incorrect to be faithfully adapted. Forrest cusses a lot and says things that would offend most people. It also doesn't help that stuff in the 2nd half of the book is too silly to be taken seriously.

Like Forrest getting in trouble with the law and going on a space mission for NASA to avoid prison time then crashlanding his ship on an island full of Cannibals. Then becomes friends with the Cannibal King who is a Yale graduate who teaches Forrest to play Chess.

Then after living with the Cannibals for 4 years he gets rescued and upon getting back meets Jenny and Liutanant Dan again and becomes a wrestler called the Dunce.

Then when that doesn't work out he goes to Los Angelous where he both enters a Chess Competition and gets to film a scene in a Creature from the Black Lagoon movie with Rachelle Welch.

Then he finally creates his Shrimping Company by getting almost every person he's ever met to help farm shrimp and to help keep track of finances. Rachelle Welch even does ads for his company.

Then he runs for Congress with the Campaign slogan, "I gotta pee!"


Now can you imagine any of that stuff being done in a serious manner? I can't.

reply

Yeah, the movie wasn't supposed to be reality. It would have been funny as hell to see him befriended by an ivy league cannibal...

reply


Wow, there's a lot of crap in that novel!!

I think they did a great job adapting it if all those bizarre scenarios were in the book.

reply

I always felt that Paramount took the simple approach of making Gomer Pyle the template for this movie. Basically a dumb but lovable guy exceeds his abilities and does well time after time. So for those of you who always longed for a Gomer Pyle movie (why not as plenty of other silly 1960's TV shows got their's) you actually got it decades ago. They even gave you a winking acknowledgement when Forrest is watching GP while in the army hospital at Saigon. I always wanted FG to turn up at Vasquez Rocks as a tourist while Star Trek (Arena) was being filmed and pressed into service playing the Gorn.

reply

They even gave you a winking acknowledgement when Forrest is watching GP while in the army hospital at Saigon.


I don't think I picked that up that Pyle reference until like the tenth time I saw this. Of course, I was never much of a fan of Gomer Pyle..



reply

It's actually a good show but suffers like other shows of that era an abundance of mediocre to poor episodes. The best 1/3 in terms of episodes are actually very entertaining. Very few shows had back to back to back episodes that were great like All in the Family. I've actually have grown to like The Andy Griffith Show but dislike any episode where Andy gives Barney a confidence boost as a deputy. Makes for good comedy but a poor example as to how to handle people in real life.

reply