The reason people hate Marisa Tomei's Oscar win...
1. She didnt star in a movie about gays
2. She didnt cry
3. She didnt speak in a British accent
4. No one had AIDS in the movie
5. More than 5 people went to see the film
6. It was a movie that made people laugh
7. She didnt pretend to be a man
8. She had the nerve to appear in a movie that appealed to a wide audience
9. She didnt star in a movie that preached to people about a social issue
10. The Coen Bros, Paul Thomas Anderson, or whatever other artsy fartsy director didnt direct it.
Basically anyone who gave Marisa Tomei grief for her Oscar win was a stuck up pretencious film snob. Tomei was laugh out loud funny and a total scene stealer in a film people liked. God forbid she beat Joan Plowright playing a cranky old hag in some bore of a film 5 people saw or Judy Davis playing a stuck up b--- (which she is in real life) in a pretencious boring unfunny lame Woody Allen effort or Vanessa Redgrave in a 10 minute role that was nothing, or Miranda Richardson who cried in 1 5 min scene in a dreadful movie.
Basically what I'm saying is that people who hate on Tomei's Oscar win can suck it.