Wow, what a letdown


After all that, I was almost hoping that Travis was going to shoot everybody (including himself) or toss them out the window and then jump. Hmm.

Okay, maybe not that exactly, but what is the big deal about this film? Don't get me wrong, I really enjoy slow-moving talky types of movies. The Straight Story is a good one that comes to mind (Stanton is in that one oddly enough, though very briefly). Lone Star is another great movie that's pretty low on action but the writing and acting are brilliant in my opinion.

The thing about "Paris" that left me cold were the characters. They might as well have been cardboard cutouts. I didn't find myself giving a damn about any of them except for Anne which I thought was played well by Aurore Clement (who is so beautiful anyway). Stanton walked around like a retard most of the time, and even the kid didn't seem to care one way or the other. I love the comment he makes to one of his schoolmates when he asks him why he has two dads. "Just lucky I guess." Boy, brilliant writing there. And Stockwell could have just phoned in his part.

By the time we get to the scene where Travis tells us all what happened, it's really too late to care. And by the way, why in the world would his wife not recognize his voice until then? And why would he really bother to tell her all of that crap (except to tell us)? Wouldn't he just say "Hey, your kid's out here, do you want him or not?"

The whole movie just falls flat on its face in my opinion.

reply

I really agree with you!!! 100%

reply

After all that, I was almost hoping that Travis was going to shoot everybody (including himself) or toss them out the window and then jump. Hmm.


I wasn't hoping for it, but expecting it. Again and again, the movie "foreshadows" catastrophic events which never happen. I don't know if this is intentional for some reason, or if the writer just runs out of ideas.

Many places in the movie this happens, where I was led to expect something awful to happen, but instead, the story just abandons the suspense and nothing happens at all, to resolve the foreshadowing.

It's not like this made me angry, but several times I was going "oh, no..." and then the scene simply changes. There isn't any turnaround, it just goes off in another direction.

reply

Just to add my 2 cents: I was also a bit disappointed by the film. Maybe my expectations were too high.

Let me start by saying that I love slow films. Hou Hsiao Hsien's 'The Assassin' is my favourite movie of the year and that is really slow and atmospheric.

I just saw the restored version of 'Paris, Texas' on a huge screen in a great theatre so the setting was right. And the film definitely has some good qualities. The music by Ry Cooder is good but it does get somewhat repetitive. There are some breathtakingly beautiful shots, although I must say not that many. Still, all nicely done.

But what lets the film down in my opinion is the acting. I thought that was kinda flat. I have never seen a film in which Kinski acts well, and I didn't find her believable in this either. Harry Dean Stanton was okay but not more than that. Dean Stockwell didn't shine either. Aurore Clément as Anne gave the only performance that I responded to on an emotional level.

So I agree with the OP: I don't really see what all the fuss is about. Not bad, 7/10.

reply

The Straight Story is a good one that comes to mind (Stanton is in that one oddly enough, though very briefly). Lone Star is another great movie that's pretty low on action but the writing and acting are brilliant in my opinion.


Well there's your problem, both those films are pedestrian.

~ I'm a 21st century man and I don't wanna be here.

reply

Yep. Abysmally boring and pointless. .....and I LOVE Harry Dean Stanton.

reply

2 hours 25 minutes to tell a poorly written and acted story. Pacing was awful, half of the scenes and/or shots had very little intent or meaning other than to show of what a great cinematographer they had. This story could have been told within 1 hour 30 minutes and a much better film it would be.

Director put all of his friends in roles so every other actor has a European accent and none of them can act, especially the wife of Dean Stockwell.

Only thing that kept me in it was Harry Dean Stanton who is a joy to watch in anything, the cinematography and the score.

reply