MovieChat Forums > One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975) Discussion > Who else could have played McMurphy in 1...

Who else could have played McMurphy in 1975?


I was thinking maybe Steve McQueen, or maybe Clint Eastwood, but I think both of them would have been far too cool to play the ranting, raving McMurphy. McMurphy is a tough guy, certainly, but there's something about him that suggests he's a loudmouthed asshole who wasn't taken very seriously outside the mental hospital. I don't think Eastwood or McQueen could have pulled that off. James Coburn, while mainly known for cool, serious roles, played a few characters who were more bark than bite, but by 1975 he might have looked too old for the role. Lee Marvin as well.

Maybe Gene Hackman or James Caan?

reply

Woody Allen. Definitely looks like he fights and fucks too much.

reply