MovieChat Forums > Chinatown (1974) Discussion > Ben Affleck to direct movie about the se...

Ben Affleck to direct movie about the secrets of ‘Chinatown’


https://nypost.com/2020/08/07/ben-affleck-to-direct-movie-about-the-secrets-of-chinatown/

reply

As usual Canadians won't like the movie.

reply

Oh, that book is not particularly interesting. Not sure how they'll make a compelling movie from it.

reply

In the tradition of "Hitchcock," and "The Offer".....nothing to get too excited about...

reply

I haven't watched The Offer. I struggled to stay awake for Hitchcock.

reply

The trouble with Hitchcock(about the making of Psycho) is that it was a Fox production and Universal owned Psycho...and refused to give the makers any clips from Psycho or to allow script dialogue to be shown being spoken. The Hitchcock heirs refused to cooperate..they felt the movie besmirched Alfred AND Alfred Hitchcock.

So you ended up with a movie about the making of Psycho that could BARELY show anything about the making of Psycho.

I've only seen clips from The Offer...Paramount did cooperate so scenes could be restaged from the film. Its better than Hitchcock in those clips. However, Peter Bart, who worked on The Godfather as a Paramount exec, is alive and says the series didn't really show what happened, and chose to pick a "hero" (producer Al Ruddy) who didn't have that kind of power, says Bart. Bart also says that a female Paramount staffer who didn't have that much to do with The Godfather was elevated "to give the series an important female character."

A big problem for these biopics about famous stars and famous directors is that you cant CAST famous stars and directors. They were UNIQUE. That's what made them stars.

I've been thinking about it, and all the GOOD gossipy stories from Chinatown revolve around the brilliant, tragic, eventually villainous director Roman Polanski. This turned out to be his final American studio film.

To wit:

Polanski returned to Hollywood fillmaking here for the first time since the slaughter of his wife Sharon Tate and their unborn child. This seemed to "feed" the gory moments of Chinatown, its dark, perverse worldview, and its downbeat ending.

Polanski and diva Faye Dunaway feuded all through the film. He plucked a hair from her head for a scene to get her "to photograph better" and she went berserk on him. Later in revenge, Dunaway threw a cup of her own urine at Polanski.

CONT





reply

Polanski and star Jack Nicholson(for whom screenwriter Robert Towne WROTE Chinatown) got along well except for a few blow ups. Jack always wanted to go off set to watch Lakers games on his private TV. Jack went berserk at Polanski's perfectionism in one scene involving venetian blinds, so Jack tore the blinds up and stormed off the set. Later, Roman tore Jack's TV out of the wall while he was watching the Lakers, so the men ended up in an angry car chase that ended in a truce.

And the big one: Polanski commandeered Robert Towne's script and changed a happy ending into a horribly unhappy one. Evidently this was with the backing of studio chief Robert Evans(also featured in The Offer) and that's the ending the movie has.

Who knows if any of the above is true. Its the legend, and I suppose a good movie can be made from it. But who can play Jack or Faye or John Huston or Polanski? Will the guy who played Robert Evans in The Offer repeat?

reply

I read the book about the making of Chinatown. I guess it seemed like a slog to me because they spent so much time talking about the writing of the script. I may give it another read in the future.

reply

I read the book about the making of Chinatown. I guess it seemed like a slog to me because they spent so much time talking about the writing of the script.

--

As with a LOT of scripts, it went though many different versions -- with different plots, different endings; with different character names , and characters who were cut out -- before reaching the screen(where Polanski put the finishing touch on the film - a switcheroo ending from Towne's script.)

I thought the interesting revelation of the book was that Robert Towne -- who got "sole" screenwriting credit on Chinatown and won the Oscar for that(the ONLY Oscar Chinatown won) ...had some guy kind of ghost writing everything for Towne. I think Towne was just a wee bit guilty when he won that Oscar.

reply

say what? towne had a ghostwriter? lol

reply