MovieChat Forums > The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011) Discussion > Continuity error? Just a minor complain...

Continuity error? Just a minor complaint…


I love this film as I do all of Fincher’s works, so I’m not meaning to nitpick but something that bothers me every time I watch is when Liv stops to pick up Mikael on his way to dinner with Martin, it’s clearly daylight out, maybe late afternoon but there is an abundance of light. And when they pull up to Martin’s house it looks as though it is late evening, it’s dark, really dark. If I understood the scene, Mikael is walking from his place on the island to Martin’s, which I’m sure could be a 20 minute walk but only a 2 minute drive, so what gives? Anyone else notice or bothered by it, especially given Fincher’s attention to detail?

reply

yes, friend, i have noticed that detail too. i pondered it a bit, and my conclusion was the same as yours that it's an odd slip by Fincher, being he is usually very meticulous.

yes i specifically remember being thrown off by the darkness, as you were. i remember wondering 'ummm, how come it's instantly dark?' (more like, WTF instead of ummm, lol)



let me just say, for anyone who has watched this as many times as i have, i know literally every single frame by heart lol and still love to rewatch this film anytime anywhere. there are some tiny odd little things i noticed about it here and there, and sometimes i posted about those, but none of those little hiccups ruined my appreciation for this masterpiece.

one is the waitress in the cafe and her resemblance to Mikail's daughter. VERY similar, visually speaking. i hate when directors make this slip-up. it throws me off because i'm wondering why he is so silent with his daughter in the cafe lol. "is he mad at her?" lol

(i made a thread about this, kinda trolling but i couldn't resist)

obviously i eventually figured out it is two different actresses, but my gripe is WHY EVEN make it close enough to place the question on anyone's radar? IMO they should do due diligence to go far enough to make a DISTINCT difference visually so no one will be distracted from the story line by wondering about silly incongruent details such as this.


anywho, this is one of my favorite films of all time. i love all of fincher's work, but this one is my ultimate favorite. can't speak highly enough of it. it just somehow strikes a nerve deep within me.... makes me wanna go to sweden and ride that train in the snow!!!






reply