He’s the best version of Peter Parker his personality is the most comic accurate version of Spider-Man He’s running rings around everyone he has more charisma then Tobey Maguire. Garfield Spider-Man is quippy but not an annoying way. He had a good back-and-forth between everybody. Extremely underrated
shareHe suffered from having the worst villains mostly.
shareGarfield (Not the cat) looked like the comics. Really tall and lanky but that didn't translate well in real life movies because he's too good-looking and jock-like. Maguire was ok but didn't have the right look. Holland is a bit better but too whiny and annoying.
But you can clearly see Garfield despite limited lines is the most talented actor of all three.