MovieChat Forums > Hachi: A Dog's Tale (2010) Discussion > Rating boosted by dog lovers?

Rating boosted by dog lovers?


Not trying to be provocative, but... (disclaimer, I'm neither a cat nor a dog man now, though had cats when I was a kid)

Do dog lovers rate this film more highly than 'regular' viewers? I've had a poke around in the message boards and it seems that there is a lot of love for the dog and discussion about his traits eg loyalty etc. There doesnt seem to be that much talk about the film, the way it is written/filmed/directe etc.

It seems to me that people who love dogs are drawn to this film ad love it becase it is about dogs. Not so many people are drawn to it as a film yet it has (at the time of writing) an 8.2 score. I can only think that a sentimental film about a dog and his relationship with the owner is triggering a big response for people with dogs. I'm not being judgemental, just trying to understand the reasons behind it's high rating.

For what it's worth, I can cry at a shaving foam advert but during this film the only hint of teariness wat the point where the wife came and found Hachi still waiting. I remained dry though. More dreary than teary. It was an unremarkable film, and gave it a 4, nothing that will stay with me beyond the viewing.

Interested in people's thoughts.

reply

You could say the same about the subject matter of any film really. Whether it's a war film, horror film, political film whatever... Your best bet is to compare this film to other films about dogs, and let's face it there's been plenty, and compare the ratings of Hachi to the rest of them. I think you'll find there's quite a lot of low rated films about dogs too.

I'm writing this signature in bold so people know it's a signature

reply

Good point. What film isn't boosted by lovers of the subject or the genre? I guess badly made films aren't, but this is very well made.

reply

"Naturally"

Do you think Fighters of the MMA overwhelmingly rated this film 8+??

Can you fly this plane?
Surely u cant be serious
I am serious,and dont call me Shirley

reply

Bit of a silly question.

That's like complaining that James Bond movies are rated highly, because they get a lot of upvotes from James Bond fans. Of course people who like dogs will be drawn to this film. It's about a dog.

reply