MovieChat Forums > Christmas Cottage (2008) Discussion > A story about thomas kinkade's life? Ar...

A story about thomas kinkade's life? Are you kidding??


I am an art major and like many people in the art world, cannot stand his work. The people that like his work tend to know nothing about art and just think his art is pretty. they need to teach the public about good art not the pathetic art that he produces. I am a fan of Jared's, even though I am not convinced he is a great actor, but he is good looking guy. He's a guilty pleasure but this movie should not be made since it will just add to the uninformed masses that think kinkade's work is fabulous. Cripes......make another Dali movie before this one. At least he's interesting.

reply

You'll be happy to know that his art, while pivotal to the plot is not focused on to any huge degree, it's more about the people, the town of Placerville, and the circumstances of his becoming a painter. In point of fact, Ed Asner's character in the film out and out tells him he's not very good. Rather, they talk about why he paints, why he paints the way he does, and how his paintings make people feel.
Honestly, you see very little of his work in the movie, mainly just one mural.

reply

I don't know what this movie will be like, but I am an art major also. I don't HATTTEEEE it but I do not like his work. I think Kinkaide's work falls in the genre of American folk art. I'm just wondering how interesting his life was to make a movie out of it. This was just so random.

reply

Very random indeed! I honestly never thought they would make a movie about Thomas Kinkade. It is a very different role for Padalecki and I am interested to see how it turns out.

I have always absolutely loved his work, however overly produced it is. I do think it is very pretty and it makes me happy to look at it. Obviously he has talent! Anyone who can make art that looks like what it's meant to has talent. You know what I mean? When he paints a house it doesn't come out looking like a blob. His trees don't look like brown sticks with green balls at the top, they actually look like trees. There is a lot of detail and beauty (in my opinion) in his paintings. His skies are always so colorful and realistic.

There are many types of art. And not everyone is going to care for his but to say he doesn't have talent is utterly ridiculous. Almost humorous.

reply

Hey, we won't know for sure until the movie is out, but I don't think this is primarily a biopic as much as a rather sentimental Christmas moviee. We'll see.


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

Yes, We will see.

reply

hmmm.....I think the movie sounds quite interesting. I think Thomas Kinkade has very nice pieces in his collection. Although I think it would be a really cool movie if they actually went inside the painting. Like made the painting come to life and there was a whole story behind the painting or something. You get what I'm trying to say right?

reply

Hey, when I first heard this movie announced, I figured it would be a story inspired by the painting. And yet, in a way, I think telling the story of exactly what inspired the painting will do just as well.


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

I hope everyone realizes that he doesn't *actually* paint all of his paintings...they're very mass-produced, thus stretching the limits of the term "art"

But of course, he doesn't really care what we think about his art. He's laughing all the way to the bank, and this movie is probably being made for the sole purpose of making more money

reply

Who would make a movie about Thomas Kinkade? Well, Thomas Kinkade, would, of course!
http://www.nysun.com/article/50538
New York Sun, March 15, 2007


"production chief of Lionsgate, Michael Paseornek, said the company hopes will be a long-term relationship. "We see Thomas Kinkade as a franchise in the film business just like he is in the art world,"

"The CEO of Thomas Kinkade Company, Dan Byrne, said that the company had been working with Mr. Campus and his company, Birch Grove Films, for a year, "developing properties that might be appealing for Thomas Kinkade Media."

I don't mind Thomas Kinkade's work, it's nice and pretty. And I don't see the problem with having art that is nice and pretty. I do dislike him as a person though. I think he's fake and he's playing the Christian angle to make money, but he's talking the talk, not walking the walk.
http://arts.guardian.co.uk/news/story/0,,1739383,00.html
Guardian Unlimited, March 25, 2006

"In court documents and other testimony, he has been accused of sexual harassment, fraudulent business practices and bizarre incidents of drunkenness including a habit of "ritual territory marking" that involves urinating in public places."

. . .

"A court-appointed arbitration panel has ruled in favour of two former owners of Kinkade-branded galleries, ordering his company to pay them $860,000 (£500,000) for breaching "the covenant of good faith and dealing" and failing to disclose pertinent business information.

The panel found that his firm "painted an unrealistic and misleading picture of the prospects of success for a dealer", while using religious language to foster an atmosphere of trust."

And he thinks a bit too much of himself.
http://www.riverfronttimes.com/2007-08-15/news/fairy-interesting/
St. Louis News - River Front Times, August 15, 2007

"A painter has a great opportunity to share art if you don't get hung up on the idea of art as an original. Andy Warhol said the greatest art is the art that is seen by the most people. The kind of work I've done over the years has been broadly accepted, just like Norman Rockwell was in his day."

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2001/11/21/60minutes/main318790.shtml
60 Minutes, July 4, 2004

"How does Kinkade regard Picasso? "I don't believe, in time, that he will be regarded as the titan that he is now," says Kinkade. "He is a man of great talent who, to me, used it to create three Picassos before breakfast because he could get $10,000 each for them."

. . .

"Thomas Kinkade is a multi-dimensional lifestyle brand, similar to Martha Stewart or Ralph Lauren," says Kinkade.

"You can put a Thomas Kinkade couch beneath your Thomas Kinkade painting. Next to the Thomas Kinkade couch goes the Thomas Kinkade end table. On top of that goes your collection of Thomas Kinkade books, Thomas Kinkade collectibles, Thomas Kinkade throw rugs. You can snuggle your Thomas Kinkade teddy bear."

And, he adds, "You can put all of that inside your new Thomas Kinkade home in the Thomas Kinkade subdivision."

More than 100 homes, all modeled on his cutesy, cozy cottages, have been built in Vallejo, Calif., outside San Francisco.

"This is ad nauseam, I know, to some people. But hear me out. My goodness. Walt Disney wasn't satisfied just making a movie. He said, 'I wanna invite people to step into that world,' and he built Disneyland," says Kinkade. "We view my work and my cultural identity, in a way, as heir to the Walt Disney kind of tradition."

What in his life is worth making a movie about? Actually a movie about his life might be pretty interesting. But "The Christmas Cottage" is simply BASED on his life, and his early life at that (this first one anyway) so I am sure that he is all cleaned up nice and shiny in it.

I like Jared Padalecki, I think he's a very talented actor. I think the same of Richard Burgi. I thought Aaron Ashmore was good in X-Men. Peter O'Toole and Marcia Gay Hardin have careers and career accolades which speak for themselves.

So I am going to see the movie, and I think it's very possible that the movie will be well-made and enjoyable, but it is, in effect, a Thomas Kinkade painting of Thomas Kinkade's life, just another Thomas Kinkade, Painter of Light(trademarked) product, not reality.

reply

Shawn Ashmore is in X-Men, not Aaron.

-Kelly-
www.Aaron-Ashmore.com

The opposite of war isn't peace. It's creation.

reply

Oh, I'm sorry!

Aaron is Jimmy Olsen in Smallville then! I've seen much more of his work and he is a good actor. It'll be interesting to see he and Jared as brothers.

reply

"I am an art major and like many people in the art world, cannot stand his work. The people that like his work tend to know nothing about art and just think his art is pretty."

You are quite the pretentious piece of crap. Going to art school does not qualify you to enjoy art anymore then the guy next to you, or the guy next to him. You don't get to say what's good and what's bad. That's not your job.

reply

Hahaha. I'm an art critic and I hate his stuff too. I mean, everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but critiquing art is literally my job.
(Plus, art students do learn a great deal about criticism. Soooo, OP may not be able to say what is enjoyable to the masses, but should be able to say what is A) well painted and B) reflective of society and relevant.)

reply

BTW, whatever happened to the OP? I'm always intrigued by those who start threads and then never return in discussion.


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

What a snob! Art is definitely in the eye of the beholder, or why else would someone hang a picture that consists of two splotches of paint on a white background and call it art. I'm not a big fan of Mr. Kinkade but I appreciate his ability to make others happy with his art and isn't that what art should be about, the ability to to touch someone with your art. I am a huge fan of Norman Rockwell but I am as much a fan of Andy Warhol. What it comes down to is what touches me emotionally. Unfortunately, some of the so-called "great paintings" of the world are nothing more than an atrocious piece of work created by someone who was in the throes of great emotional distress and chose to take out his/her misery on a piece of canvas.All Ican say is give me poker playing dogs over a splotch of paint on a canvas anyday.

reply

Hey, hey, there's nothing wrong with pop art that the masses enjoy any more than there's anything wrong with pop music everyone enjoys. Bottom line though is the movie appears to be about people, not art. We'll know a year from now.


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

Exactly, it's not like the movie is going to be a slide show of Kinkade's work.

reply

Hey, hey, I have little opinion of the man's art, but as a Boston Red Sox fan recently relocated to Indianapolis, I have to say that any artist who's currently wrking on a portrait of Fenway Park can't be all bad.


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

Your reply is really ignorant! I have 2 BFA degrees from 2 of the best art schools in the US and I am a visual artist in many respects including fine art, illustration, sculpture and film (including acting). I don't claim to know everything at all! I am learning everyday...however, you know so little about art, film and acting to be able to publicly share an opinion like that. It's ok to have one as long as it is educated, dispite whether it is disagreeable to others.

reply

Hey, hey, what's so ignorant about applauding any artist doing a portrait of Fenway Park. Ae you a fan of the damn N.Y. Yankees or something?


Merry Christmas! Ho, ho, ho!

reply

[deleted]