MovieChat Forums > The Visitor (2008) Discussion > TOP TEN PLOT HOLES: Here we gooooooooooo...

TOP TEN PLOT HOLES: Here we gooooooooooooo....... .........


True it is a touching film that tugs at the old hard strings. But really! Come on! Why can't anyone ever write a flawless movie that doesn't have any plot holes? It's starting to wear really thick on me. For example:

1.How could a PHD educated university professor afford two homes when he only teaches one class a weak and pretends to write books? DUH! 2.How could the piano teacher possibly have known that she was his 5th piano instructor and that he actually wanted to sell his keyboard? DUH! 3. Why would a PHD educated university professor lend his keys to a Rushing immigrant? DUH! 4. Why did the PHD university professor tell the young couple "Who is IVUN?" after he had lent him the keys in the first place? DUH! 5.How is it even possible to survive in New York the BIG RED APPPLE by holding garage sales and playing a drum in a park with approximately 40 other people? DUH! 6.How did the New York City Police Department know that the Arab terrorist would try to break the law at a particular bus stop? DUH! 7.How can a so called ILLEGAL ALIEN even survive when he/she is clearly illegal and on the run all the time? DOUBLE DUH! 8. How come the police officer with the latest computer technology didn't even know where the terrorist went? DUH! 9. Why would a PHD educated university professor choose to live with a woman who admits she is ILLEGAL just like the terrorist? DUH! 10. Why would a PHD university educated professor choose to become an ILLEGAL alien himself by banging on a drum in a public place without a permit? Triple DUH! DUH! DUH! Expecially after all the other ILLEGAL aliens were already gone back to Pakistan and there was no longer any need to listen to them any more? DUH! DUH! DUH! DUH! DUH!

Overall, it was an okay film, however as you can see there were lots of problems with continuity and such. I give it a C+.

reply

Everyone of your so-called "plot holes" are debatable for the sake of this well written story. In fact, some of your questions make me wonder if you were paying attention at all. Nice try though.

Million Dollar Baby Academy Award® Winner for Best Picture of 2004

reply

If a guy writes an intentionally absurd post and everyone gets pissed at him and calls him and idiot, who's the real idiot?

reply

I don't think it was intentionally absurd! It was too long-winded. He/she is still an idiot though!

reply

[deleted]


hahahah I just can not believe u and I watched the same movie :)
I really hate to breathe the same athmosphere with the people LIKE YOU...

--------------
Even if I dissaprove what you think! I will defend your right to say it!

reply

This was actually extremely funny,
he made a list of ten plots holes,
none of which actually rang true.

This guy should stick to watching cartoons,
it's not as if the film was in any way complicated,
it's like he watched a completely different film.

reply

It's so ironic that these two sentences exist in the same post....



I really hate to breathe the same athmosphere with the people LIKE YOU...

--------------
Even if I dissaprove what you think! I will defend your right to say it!

reply

What two sentences are you talking about my dear friend blitius?

reply

dumbest OP of the year?

reply

If not, then a serious contender!

reply

these were the most fcked up critics I have ever seen

http://www.imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=24795200
take a look:)

reply

The threadstarter has problems to pay attention.

reply

aliens were already gone back to Pakistan
What an ignorant.

You remind me of the lady in the movie who went to Cape Town (which is thousands of kilometers from Senegal).

reply

HAHAHAhAHahahhah... bus stop...

reply

What a waste of a thread. The OP is a moron.

reply