Medically inaccurate movie


The movie was great until Maggie ended up in the hospital. There were so many glaring things wrong with the last third of the movie, it ruined my experience.

The most obvious error was when she was talking on the ventilator. But there are other grievances. For instance, they attach the ventilator straight to her trach tube. That is a big no-no. Especially for invasive long-term mechanical ventilation. She would need some humidity, at least an HME. Even then, she says (ironically) that she has a C1, C2 complete (paralysis), an injury which impairs or ceases one's ability to speak.

Then there were other things. For instance, the lack of security in the hospital, especially for the CRITICAL CARE patients like Maggie, which are usually locked up. Plus, hospital patient rooms are usually locked up at night, people cannot waltz in and out as they please.

Also the epinephrine (it is never explained where Frankie got it from) amount that was injected into Maggie was wayyyyyyy too much. Yes, I know that he was trying to kill her, but the amount he gave her would have given her violent, severe seizures for several minutes before a possible cardiac arrest. Plus, the nurses would have came immediately since she was crashing. The alarm that he "silenced" only silences the audible alarms on the ventilator, not the nurse call alarm.

Hospitals don't fool around with patient safety, Eastwood just made a weak ending because he thought the audience wouldn't know any better.

Don't they hire people to check out these things? It was all very unrealistic, yet somehow this film won 4 academy awards, including best picture.

reply

The trouble is you only noticed these things because clearly you have a reasonable amount of medical knowledge... yet you didn't mind the 'glaring errors' in the boxing community when 'the Blue Bear' acted in a way which would have gotten her banned for life and/or imprisoned... so wouldn't have been in the ring in the first place because it was clear that she was always doing things like that.

My point being a movie is nearly always going to be 'wrong' for people 'in the know'.

reply

I agree. I also notice they get a LOT of things wrong in zombie movies!!

reply

This is an old post and you will probably never see this but:

Maggie wasnt in a hospital. She was in a long term care facility. Youd be surprised how disastrously bad the staff there often is. Thats where all those nurses who couldnt get a license to be a proper nurse go. Ive seen cases where patients literally starved to death because the nurses didnt care. If Frank wouldnt be coming every day she would have been far, far off than shown in the movie.

The alarms can be silenced and i saw doctors do it for crashing patients when the family has signed agreement not to resuscitate (too old, would just torture the poor person). Not all of them are hooked into the nurses point, and furthermore it was shown in the movie that the nurse "went out for coffee". Given how often ive see nurses nest vacant myself even during day shifts, i can totally believe it would be such on a slow night.

reply