MovieChat Forums > Caché (2006) Discussion > Is one of the film's messages is that...

Is one of the film's messages is that...


... many if not all people form their official de-facto personalities and traits since childhood, and that, like in the George case for instance, if you lied and bullied someone seriously in childhood, you are likely to continue to have such characteristics in your adult life tens of years later. Correct?

Granted, some people CAN and even DO change, yes. We also hold adults for many obvious (and some less so, at least on first count) reasons to a higher level of accountability and responsibility for their deeds than children, but most of them form their personality in childhood years, correct?

So if you were mostly mean as naughty as a child, you are likely to continue to act in similar and possibly worse ways as an adult, yes? And this is at least partially what the movie is about and how the conflict between George and Majid started in childhood and escalated into something more serious and sinister in their adult years, agree?

I thought so!

reply

I agree. This is a decent take on the film and it's not an aspect I considered after watching.

For sure, his indifference to how he acted as a child persisted into his life later on. I think that can be seen with how he runs his household in some degree, with how he talks/treats his wife at times in some scenes.

It also then begs the question (see the old imdb posts for multiple discussions) who was doing the filming and taping. There are a lot of different views on that, but if we are to believe the filming is out of spite or hate from when they were younger, then it is obvious Majid is the one recording. However, that is one opinion of quite a few down below.

reply

If George is a PSYCHOPATH (technically what's called having an ANTI SOCIAL PERSONALITY DISORDER according to the DSM), then YES you're right about how it's HIGHLY UNLIKELY he'd change later on in life.

And the CALLOUS way that he goes to see the MOVIE after the SUICIDE takes place also confirms for me that he fits into that kind of a CATEGORY.

Plus he'd also have had to MOVE the BODY out of his way to get out of the door.

Which also means he did that, and then LEFT it laying there for someone else to find.

Imagine sitting through a FILM after you've just seen someone you know killing themselves !!!

😧




reply

That behavior foretells George's sociopathic tendencies.

reply