MovieChat Forums > Inglourious Basterds (2009) Discussion > Why did Landa let Shosanna go at the beg...

Why did Landa let Shosanna go at the beginning?


It doesn't make sense since he seemed so hell-bent on finding and murdering Jews. If he was that obsessed with murdering every single Jew across the French landscape why let her go (and laugh about it)?

My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

Most likely for sport. Landa seemed to enjoy himself while interrogating the farmer so he just wanted to keep the business alive and interesting.

reply

Thanks; it makes sense. 

My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

Calvin: Check out jcdugger's post.


My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

No that wasn't it lol!

From the script, you can see exactly why he let her go...


EXT - NAZI TOWN CAR (MOVING)- DAY
Colonel Hans Lan
speeding away from the French farm house.
Landa speaks to his Driver in GERMAN, SUBTITLED into ENGLISH;

COL LANDA
Herman, I sense` a question on your lips?
Out with it?

DRIVER
Why did you allow a enemy of the state
to escape?

COL LANDA
Oh, I don't think the state is in too
much danger, do you?

DRIVER
I suppose not.

COL LANDA
I'm glad you see it my way. Besides,
not putting a bullet in the back of a
fifteen year old girl, and allowing
her to escape, are not necessarily
the same thing. She's a young girl, no food,
no shelter, no shoes, who's just witnessed
the massacre of her entire family.
She may not survive the night. And after
word spreads about what happened today,
it's highly unlikely she will find any
willing farmers to extend her aid.
If I had to guess her fate, I'd say she'll
probably be turned in by some neighbour.
Or, she'll be spotted by some German
soldier. Or, we'll find her body in the
woods, dead from starvation or exposure.
Or, perhaps-she'll survive. She will
elude capture. She will escape to America.
She will move to New York city.
Where she will be elected, President of
the United States.
The S.S. Colonel chuckles at his little funny.

TITLE CARD:"INGLORIOUS BASTERDS"

reply

Thanks, JC.

While what you say comes from the script, it doesn't necessarily negate what Calvin says above, that Landa let her get away for sport, enjoying his power over life and death. She presented no danger to the state and would either die in the woods, be turned-in by frightened French people or escape to another country. Whatever the case, it was fun for Landa to decide on a whim to let her go, not to mention it would keep his business alive and interesting.


My 150 (or so) favorite movies:
http://www.imdb.com/list/ls070122364/

reply

I'm glad you see it my way. Besides,
not putting a bullet in the back of a
fifteen year old girl, and allowing
her to escape, are not necessarily
the same thing. She's a young girl, no food,
no shelter, no shoes, who's just witnessed
the massacre of her entire family.
She may not survive the night. And after
word spreads about what happened today,
it's highly unlikely she will find any
willing farmers to extend her aid.
If I had to guess her fate, I'd say she'll
probably be turned in by some neighbour.
Or, she'll be spotted by some German
soldier. Or, we'll find her body in the
woods, dead from starvation or exposure.
Or, perhaps-she'll survive. She will
elude capture. She will escape to America.
She will move to New York city.
Where she will be elected, President of
the United States.
The S.S. Colonel chuckles at his little funny.

Or she might carefully plan the destruction of 300 Nazi officers by luring them into her theatre, locking them in and then burning them all to death... ha ha ha how wrong he was.

reply

Well, Col. Landa was an unbelievably arrogant individual who made it very clear the amount of disdain and contempt he had for the people around him in almost every word he says to another person. It isn't until the final moment that he's outsmarted by someone "intellectually inferior" who managed to hit him where it hurt most. Of course he'd never believe a teenage French Jewish girl could manage to come into a position of power that would allow her the ability to punish the entire Nazi high command.

"KatTS" / "KoC" / "DP" / "SAM" / "K"

reply

It's funny. If the plan to have the Bastards blow up the theater didn't happen he might have stumbled on her plot.

reply

[deleted]

In the movie she is estimated to be 18-19 years old. So I guess they changed that.

"You'll be taking a soul train straight to a disco inferno where you never can say goodbye!"

reply

As for Landa killing her personally. She was running full-tilt and by the time he could get off an aimed shot she was already 40-50 yards away, every second he hesitated bought here another 5 yards. Hitting her at 40-50 yards would take an excellent/lucky pistol-shot, by the time he looked like he might shoot she was probably closer to 100 yards away.

It would have diminished his reputation if he shot several times and missed her completely, which was the very likely outcome. Of course, they could have pursued her and likely gotten or shot her, but at that point, he probably did not think it was worth the trouble and she'd probably turn up anyhow...

reply