Beautiful Propaganda.


I don't know if anybody sensed this idea of Japanese propaganda in the movie, but I sure did. I may be overstating it, but the element is definately there. The mysterious man represents the country itself, Japan, and the actress symbolizes the Japanese people. The whole story of searching for that person that the actress love so much is the actual search for the dignity and love for Japan. Do you remember a line in the movie where the actress says, "I will never betray him!". It is a subliminal message to the Japanese to never betray Japan. Also, in the first scenes of the actress's memories, there is a reference to Japan's invasion of Manchuria. The movie talks about how the Japanese soldiers are fighting for their "country" and how they want to serve their country. We all know that Japan's attack on Manchuria was horrible and hostile. Not many people know how strong the Japanese propaganda is. Not many people know that the Japanese school books lie about the wars in the 20th century. Those books justifices their attack on Asian countries and teaches young Japanese that "they" were the ones that were tricked. Yes, it still goes on these days. Many Asian countries criticize Japan for it, but Japan is too strong a country to oppose harshly. Anyway, you have to understand that kind of "strong nationalism" is sometimes corporated in the Japanese movies. Just be aware of it. You have to read between the lines.

reply

You're overanalyzing... And really, 90% of all hollywood movies are shock full of propaganda. Take the Transformers movie. It's basically a two hour commercial for the US army...

reply

[deleted]

The OP is wrong. It is likely that Satoshi Kon was Korean-Japanese, or ethnically Korean based on his name. In future movies, he used Korean animators to animate his movies. Korean Japanese are a hidden minority in Japan; they retain Korean citizenship and have no means due to Japanese immigration law, of becoming Japanese even if born in the country (as Satoshi Kon was). They usually keep their status a secret to fit in and avoid discrimination. It is true that the imagery of Japan's pre-20th century history is beautiful in this film. There's no reason to doubt Kon loved Japan since it's the country he's always known.

It is telling that the mysterious man was opposed to Japan's war of imperialism, is killed by a nationalist, and he is the hidden hero that inspires the actress.

reply

rtsong is spot on.

Having just seen this film for the first time, I am absolutely baffled that anyone could misinterpreted it as being Japanese propaganda.

It is the very polar opposite of nationalistic - it's a humanist film, exposing the brutality and injustice of unfettered nationalism.

Chiyoko's elusive dissident lover was one of those scapegoated for the 1931 Manchurian crisis, otherwise known as the Mukden incident. The film couldn't be more explicit about this, even featuring the explosion of the railroad section of the Japanese railway, which immediately preceded the conflict.

As we discover during the course of the film, Koichi was one of those who was tortured and killed on suspicion of being involved in the explosion, but as a confession was never obtained, it is never clear precisely what level of involvement, if any, he had in the explosion.

However, the fact that the man who was responsible for torturing and killing him ends up before Chiyoko on his knees begging for her forgiveness is the clearest possible signifier that this in no way, shape, or form a pro-nationalist film.

Whilst it is apparent that Chiyoko the actress was used by the studio who employed her for propaganda purposes, to suggest that the film itself is a work of propaganda, is pure fantasy.

reply

Not many people know that the Japanese school books lie about the wars in the 20th century.


how do u know your history books arent lying aswell.

reply

“Education is what remains after one has forgotten everything he learned in school.” - Albert Einstein

reply

Have you seen Men Behind the Sun?

I Sympathize with Lars Von Trier.

reply

What did the Japanese ever do to you?

reply