MovieChat Forums > Girlfight (2000) Discussion > Million dollar baby, rip off?

Million dollar baby, rip off?


Hey million dollar baby's only just coming out over here in the UK. i was wondering if any of you 'girlfight' fans had seen it and had any opinion on wether its a hollywood rip off or worth seeing. I loved girlfight so i'm sceptical about this 'million dollar baby'

reply

Million Dollar Baby is a really good movie but extremly slowwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww any Michelle Rodriguez movie is always kickin ass full of attitude and she is sooooo sexy so girlfight will def be faster paced

reply

Girlfight was made before Million Dollar Baby... so which one is the rip-off??

reply

how about niether?
How many movies have been made by male boxers? A few... and I haven't read anything about them being a rip off.

Now all of a sudden 2 movies come out about a female boxer and one's ripping the other.

Just watch both movies, enjoy them for what they are, and that's that. If u consider one to be a rip off, that's your opinion, but half these people who are posting about it being a rip off probably didnt see both movies.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

oh PUH-LEASE!!! million dollar baby was a direct rip-off of girlfight! i was amazed at how many similarities these 2 films had!!! the only reason that MDB was awarded and got nominated for so many oscars was because the 3 leading characters...were...guess what...3 previous oscar winners/nominees!!! and the director was...yep...good ol' dirty harry!!! (...also, a higher budget than girlfight) but, if you put these 2 films to be judged on the script itself, girlfight would win by far. MDB was overwritten, and started to get a bit annoying at times. 3 hours was way too long. they should've ended it when she broke her kneck on the stool in the ring. i started to drift off towards the last hour. Girlfight had me on the edge of my seat from start to finish. the whole thing was powerful. the first kiss between michelle and santiago...that had me in awe...girlfight all the way!

reply

Thats the stupidest thing i ahve seen in a long time

reply

How in the HELL is this a rip off of Million Dollar Baby when this came out before it. Seriously, what are you even talking about?

I am Queens Boulevard.

reply

we're saying Million Dollar Baby is a rip-off of girlfight...not the other way around

reply

MDB is crap, the story is completely unbelievable, the numble of people who love it just shows how many mugs there are out there.

reply

[deleted]

Bravo Smooba

reply

Girl fight came out in 2000. end of discussion

reply

[deleted]

Raging Bull and Million Dollar Baby are absolute masterpieces; Girlfight is not.

reply

haha

reply

yeah i can only agree with you... LMFAO!!!! what it is with people? rip-off or not, this is one of the best movies ever.. :)

reply

I cant say that MDB is a ripoff of Girlfight but I definatly think that Girlfight made it there first. I have a thread like this going in the MDB boards. If you want to contribute go here http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0405159/board/flat/33733970?d=33954893#33954893 but before you say anything please remember what I say is all IMO.
------------------------
We don't go to Ravenholm
Ironside as Sam DUH!

reply

This thread made me laugh so hard.


Girl fight came out in 2000. end of discussion

MDB was based on a book that was released way before Girlfight. Discussion does not end just because you pipe up with a statement without even doing any background research and get it all wrong.

How in the HELL is this a rip off of Million Dollar Baby when this came out before it. Seriously, what are you even talking about?


Read the entire thread before posting. It is only the title that was badly phrased.

MDB is crap, the story is completely unbelievable


How can it be unbelievable? Women can box, women can get paralysed, women can engage in Euthanasia. These things happen. It's not like there were flying pigs or zombies in it or anything.

Meh.

"Nevermore."
http://www.mindistortion.net/iwantyoursoul/?i_am=TheRaevyn

reply

"MDB was based on a book that was released way before Girlfight. Discussion does not end just because you pipe up with a statement without even doing any background research and get it all wrong."


maybe clint saw this movie, and then decided to make his own movie about a female boxer by using the book that mdb is based on. :)
either way, the only one who could answer that would be clint, and even then there's no guarantee that he would tell the truth.

reply