MovieChat Forums > Midsomer Murders (1998) Discussion > Stop the "token" Black and Asian minorit...

Stop the "token" Black and Asian minorities.


I am not in the least bit racist but Midsomer has become a farce with its token use of black and Asian actors since its controversy.

The way the producers are insisting on non-white faces in the background and randomly just turning up is so false it is turning the show in to a comedy for all the wrong reasons.

So the new Asian pathologist goes on a course and is replaced by a black doctor who talks like he has just walked off the set of Attack the Block innit.

Pleeeeeeeease.............just use actors who fit the part and stop pandering to politically correct race quotas.

reply

I am not in the least bit racist but Midsomer has become a farce with its token use of black and Asian actors since its controversy.


Agreed and personally I have no problem with ethnic minority characters in MM providing they are legitimate suspects, are the actual murderers on a reasonably regular basis and most important of all: are plausibly ethnic in relation to their character types.

MM's writers these days though seem to regard their respective guest casts as almost completely interchangeable, which is often ludicrous given the show's rural setting and the characters one would realistically expect to encounter in such an environment.

Yes, Midsomer is a purely fictional county with an equally fictional homicide rate but it still has to have a grounding in reality for viewers to regard it as a plausible premise.

The way the producers are insisting on non-white faces in the background and randomly just turning up is so false it is turning the show in to a comedy for all the wrong reasons.


The irony is ITV now likely has to 'bus in' a fair few of its newly strategically diverse 'background artists' whereas before they were probably all locals. Pathetic really and the sheer crudity of it all is so amateurish.

So the new Asian pathologist goes on a course and is replaced by a black doctor who talks like he has just walked off the set of Attack the Block innit.


I've yet to see the last episode of the current series but it rather sounds like I've got a real 'treat' to look forward too with such a character..... 

Pleeeeeeeease.............just use actors who fit the part and stop pandering to politically correct race quotas.


Again agreed but fat chance ITV will remedy anything soon given that the channel's seemingly on a mission, nay crusade to prove to the world they are definitely not waycist.....even though MM's global audience neither wanted nor required such trite affirmation of divine righteousness anyway.

So sad. So avoidable. 


reply

Has there ever been a Polish character? Where I live, they're the largest ethnic minority.

reply

Has there ever been a Polish character? Where I live, they're the largest ethnic minority.


Hmm, curious, from which rural English village do you hail from then?

Regardless, I fear by implication you overestimate how 'diversity' is usually defined by your average virtue-signalling/left-leaning telly type.

Indeed one could have a cast boasting a plethora of Polish, Lithuanian, Estonian, Slovakian et al characters/actors.....but that doesn't qualify as diverse to the aforementioned telly types because such a cast would still be white (or "hideously white" if you're Greg Dyke ).

No, diversity = blackface (not in the Al Jolson sense) and anything less doesn't qualify which is why MM implausibly resembles a f^cking Benetton commercial these days.

reply


Hmm, curious, from which rural English village do you hail from then?


In Cheshire, which is fairly rural, Polish is the 2nd most common language. Slovakian is 3rd. When there were complaints that Cheshire Constabulary only had a couple of non-white officers, the chief constable said there were very few potential recruits. Somebody then suggested that he brought them in from other areas. So much for local policing!


Regardless, I fear by implication you overestimate how 'diversity' is usually defined by your average virtue-signalling/left-leaning telly type


No, I wasn't really being serious there. I know what you mean. In the real world, I think you would be more likely to come across a Polish builder than an Indian one. But, even in rural England, you would still have found Indian doctors, and Chinese dentists etc..

reply

Sausages

reply

Indeed.This policy is laughable.

reply

I completely agree with you. Of course it was stupid of producer Brian True-May to call Midsomer Murders a last bastion of Englishness. I don't live in Britain, but I guess few people would have complained about the lack of minorities if he had said it so explicitly.
But now they gone to the other extreme trying so hard to be as polically correct as possible. Unfortunately it is not the only reason why Midsomer has got worse. I miss John Nettles and his sidekicks and the humour that was an essential part of the old MMs.

reply

but I guess few people would have complained about the lack of minorities if he had said it so explicitly.


Well the 'sharks' were certainly circling MM at around the time of his unfortunate, career-ending choice of words I recall with 'questions' frequently being asked in certain quarters as to why the show was so "hideously white" (as Gregg Dyke used to say ).

By "sharks" I'm of course referring to race-hustlers/Guardian readers who otherwise scarcely give a sh^t about MM for the most part, let alone watch/like it. Didn't stop them having a problem with it though and demanding changes. Naturally.

But now they gone to the other extreme trying so hard to be as polically correct as possible.


What pisses me off is how crudely executed it all feels these days with each episode's respective cast of characters assigned a box-ticking quota - seemingly at random.

Contrary to what the producers appear to believe the majority of MM's eccentric assortment of rogues aren't ethnically interchangeable - particularly given their social environment, and such instances are annoyingly distracting not to mention implausible.

Such a shame. 

reply

I totally agree! They should've kept it authentic. I still watch, but sometimes it's like a Benetton advertisement.

reply

I totally agree. It's like, "Where can we shove in another minority, here?" It looks forced.

reply

And all of those gay characters. These shows have become nothing more than propaganda platforms.

reply