(That part where Gordie sees the deer while everybody is still asleep in the woods. It just seemed so random and stupid to me. Why would he make a big deal about seeing a deer and vow not to share that moment with anyone else? That's what I thought anyways. Others may take that differently of course. )
______________________________________________
I'm with you on this...I feel the same way. Sure, it depends on where you live, but I see deer all the time, no big deal....AND, this would be true for some kids living in 1950's Oregon I'm sure. It's not like he saw a grizzly, that would have been a little different.
That bit is a lot more effective in the original novella than in the movie. It's not so much that he saw a deer; it's that he had this totally private moment early in the morning where something beautiful happened, and he didn't share it with anybody, because it was just for him. I think it's actually saying something about writing; the bond between writer and reader can be so intense that it's almost like just keeping something to yourself. It's so personal that it goes beyond even the bonds between close friends.
It also seems to take a lot longer in the book. You understand that it was a fleeting moment and obviously the deer ran away almost as soon as it saw him, but because it takes a while to read what he wrote about it, the moment seems to draw out and out and out, and becomes this timeless little cool thing experienced only by Gordie.
Get on up.
reply
share