Leia wasn't remembering Padmé


The scene where she and Luke were talking about their real parents actually still works if you interpret it a certain way.

You see, the argument goes that Princess Leia could not have remembered Padmé Amidala, hers and Luke's birth mother, because she died right after she had the twins. Some argue that Leia had a Force imprint from Padmé in her mind. However, this doesn't really make much sense, because Luke should have had one too, and Padmé wasn't Force Sensitive like her children or husband were.

An interesting aside here: if you read the novelization of ROTJ, during this scene, Luke has a brief Force vision of a dying woman in a "hospital" setting, with two babies, meaning him and Leia.

However, another way to interpret this is, Leia was remembering a different mother than Padmé. Remember that she was adopted by Bail Organa, who was the consort of Queen Breha Organa, ruler of Alderaan. You see them briefly in one scene near the end of ROTS, where he brings baby Leia to the Queen, and she falls in love with the baby immediately. So the "kind, but sad" woman Leia was remembering could easily have been Breha Organa, and she most certainly could have died when Leia was very young, leaving her to be raised as a child and a teenager by Bail Organa.

reply

Yeah right. Get real. It's clear as fucking day that Luke was referring to Mrs Organa as something other than Leia Organa's "real" mother.

I have known women who if you asked them a specific question they will usually answer with different and sometimes the exact opposite terms from what you specified e.g. "What's your departure time?" - "I arrive at 3pm"; "What time does your mother arrive?" "Not yet." But I don't think the movie was trying to depict a perverse person who willfully speaks at crossed purposes.

reply

Another possibility is that this whole plot point was simply retconed by Revenge of the Sith. It's possible that at the time Return of the Jedi was made the idea was that only Luke was separated from their mom after being born. Then when Revenge of the Sith came along they changed the story and instead had Padme die immediately after giving birth.

reply

I've heard fan theories over the years about the idea that Leia stayed with hers and Luke's mom for a time after they were born, but like you said, that all went out the window when they had Padmé die right after giving birth.

It's why I've floated the theory that Leia was remembering Breha instead of her birth mother.

reply