MovieChat Forums > A Bridge Too Far (1977) Discussion > So James Caan's character doesn't approv...

So James Caan's character doesn't approve of whisky......


....and calls it garbage and thinks it's bad for his buddy to drink........yet he chain smokes like a trooper all the time??? Er. okaaaaaaay!!

reply

Gettin' 'hosed' before a jump is a bad idea--either airsickness wise, or sobering up wise; now smoking...that's a time honored way to calm the nerves & take the edge off of hunger, thirst, boredom, etc;





Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

Gettin' 'hosed' before a jump is a bad idea--either airsickness wise, or sobering up wise; now smoking...that's a time honored way to calm the nerves & take the edge off of hunger, thirst, boredom, etc;


Well he wasn't hosed and there wasn't much left in the bottle anyway. He was never going to get blotto on that tiny bit. And it wasn't the same day as the jump. A bit of booze can give you a good nights sleep and calm the nerves, moreso than smoking. It was in the daytime before. He wasn't having a tipple the night before. Plenty of time to not be affected the next day. Not talking about getting paralytic here of course. Nothing wrong with a bit of a tipple. Wasn't even 100 ml left in the bottle.

Booze is an even more time honoured way of calming the nerves than smoking. The Russians gave vodka to their men as daily rations and it didn't do them any harm. The Royal Navy had beer and rum as their daily rations for centuries.

Caan's character called whisky 'garbage'. He didn't say anything about air sickness or sobering up. He said that 'garbage' isn't going to keep him alive..yet there he is chain smoking. That certainly isn't going to keep him alive either. The point I'm making is that cigarettes are just as much 'garbage' as a bit of whisky.

It's hilarious that he called whisky 'garbage' while smoking like a chimney. That's an oxymoron if ever there was one.

reply

Well if it was rum...that'd be different. But 'smokes' were, back in the day, not known to be harmful-at least not in the short run.





Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

I dunno, Nick there were already people back then claiming that cigarettes were bad for you, including oddly enough the Nazis, who really disapproved of them.
Aparently RN seamen were often blotto during battles. It reducedd their fear and even boosted their performance a little- ever notice that after a couple of beers you get better at pool?, probably because you feel relaxed. Of course the more pissed you get the more incompetent you get so drink drive laws exist for a reason.

Trust me. I know what I'm doing.

reply

The Germans thought highly of alcohol too; I recall a quote from 'Forgotten Soldier' that a bottle of Vodka or "Terek Liquor" could really pump up a guy before battle-of course they were already in the trenches waiting to either go over the top or repel the next wave of "Popovs".






Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply

Yeah you're both right. As I said I wasn't talking about getting paralytic but rather a tipple for 'Dutch Courage'. I see nothing wrong with that, if others are smoking like chimneys hehe.

reply

Captain was drinking Scotch, could be Caan was a bourbon man

He smokes like a trooper because he is a trooper

Get over it



In a world where a carpenter can be resurrected, anything is possible.





reply

Oh no, all movies have to be "politically correct" now.

They need to use CGI to remove the cigarettes and "demon booze" from movies.

Kinda like when they removed the shotguns from ET.

reply

Kinda like when they removed the shotguns from ET.

That actually happened... I thought it was just a South Park joke until I looked it up just now. I am speechless.

reply

..it was in the days when even doctors endorsed smoking.

reply

Back then, they didn't know the true dangers of smoking. Pregnant women smoked without giving it a second thought.

reply

Yeah, people have weird hangups like that.

reply