MovieChat Forums > Morte a Venezia (1971) Discussion > On the subject of paedophilia

On the subject of paedophilia


I know everyone has their own thoughts on Aschenbach's love for Tadzio - this is just mine (based on the movie, as I'm still re-reading the book and have forgotten what happens).

First of all just like everyone else (except, and sometimes including, paedophiles) I'm heartily against child abuse of any kind. I do find Tadzio's seductiveness in the film odd (swinging on the poles on the beach) but in light of how we're shown Aschenbach's family life, I think we're to presume that he's not gay, nor normally drawn to minors. I also think that despite his obsessive behaviour, and his daydream of touching Tadzio's hair that he wouldn't act on his feelings.

I know a couple - two ladies - who, for most of their lives, were each married to men but are now together and completely in love and completely devoted to each other and they've said to me, "We're not gay. We're just in love with each other," and that's how I feel about Aschenbach's love for Tadzio. That it just so happened that Tadzio was a fifteen year old boy but perhaps he could have been a fifty year old woman (not that that would have been a very interesting film).

I know that's simplifying it a bit, and maybe I just like to avoid the sinister, but it's such a beautiful film....!

reply

I agree too. My best friend girl-friend married with children her husband left her and the children. Just because he didn't want to be married any longer. Well my best friend who is a lesbian pursuede this woman until she agree to go out on a date with her almost a year later. They have been together now twenty yeas. At one time they did break up only because my friend wanted more out of the relationship intimate things. This woman stated that she wasn't attracted to any female and actually went out on a date with a male until my friend made amends with her.
It's weird how we are attracted to someone and not in a sexual way. Well except with Michael T. Weiss or Billy Wirth in my case.

reply

He didn't pursue Tadzio bec it was forbidden, a taboo. But I bet you as soon as society and the law deems it acceptable or if he grew up in such an environment, he would've acted on his desires.

reply