Cutest Brother???


Everyone has their favorite brother who they like the best...BUT!..in all honesty who do you think is the CUTEST!!!!
My list:

1. Benjamin
2. Frank
3. Caleb
4. Ephraim
5. Adam (without the wig and disguise no.4)
6. Gideon
7. Daniel




reply

[deleted]


OK this is easy....

Howard Keel is sooo incredibly handsome until he shaves off his beard (frown). Ditto for Benjamin who looks great with a beard, but survives the shave as a breath-taking cutie. That leaves Frank with those doe-eyes and dimpled chin.

My idea of heaven is listening to Lonesome Polecat over and over. Absolutely phony emoting, but it still makes my eyes well up every time.
So sweet, so sad, so melodic, and six out of seven bros.

reply

Benjamin is the cutest but Caloeb is the sexiest!!!

reply

Benjamin, without a doubt!

reply

Frank, then Adam then Benjamin

Frank was gorgeous. And what a dancer. You should look at some of his stuff on youtube. He did a scene in a musical with Bob fosse and looks like he's flying at one point.
amazing.
Wish I was born 60 years earlier so I coulda married him!

reply

DEFINITELY Benjamin!! :)

reply

Frank. From the moment he's battling his brothers he melts me. Divine in his long red underwear, handsome when he shaves and a magnificent dancer, he's the epitome of a star.

Benjamin's not bad to look at, but that's about it.

So much time and so little to do. Wait a minute. Strike that. Reverse it.

reply

They all stink, with that minds.

reply

1. Benjamin
2. Ephraim
3. Gideon
4. Frank
5. Adam
6. Daniel
7. Caleb

reply

[deleted]

1. Frank
2. Benjamin
3. Adam
4. Caleb
5. Gideon (would've been higher up but he looked so unnatural!)
6. Ephraim
7. Daniel

But Frank's most definitely my #1! I like a boy with a bit of a scowl and a hot temper, but a good heart. Makes me melt a bit <3

reply

Ben is the hottest physically. That is a MAN!

I love Frank's hot temper, both about his name and in anything else. Gideon is such a sweetheart, and quite the little scrapper (with that family, he'd have to be).

Ephraim really gets me, too, for some reason.

reply

It's between 3 or 4:

Gideon: Sweet innocence, cute round baby face, trying to keep up with his older brothers and tries to do the right thing, great dancer

Frank: great dancer, a softie under his hot-tempered exterior, seemed to form the closest bond with Millie, his new "big sister" (remember when he kissed her on the cheek in "Going Courting" and danced with her at the barn raising?)

Caleb: Best overall talent, IMHO. Loved his smooth-sounding tenor and dance moves, his movements had a certain elegance, in a way, and his beard gave him an elfin look, which I love.

Daniel: Great dancer, his somewhat "dorky" appearance was actually charming

Benjamin: Definitely hot, but his personality was a bit too "harsh" for my tastes

Ephraim: OK, but didn't really get to know his character very well. He did have a unique look, however.

Adam: Rich-sounding baritone, but I couldn't marry him b/c I can't cook!!

Edited to add: I just read that Matt Maddox didn't actually sing. Shucks! Oh well, I still loved Caleb.

reply

Frank! Hands down, no competition!

He's so cute and I agree with Sharon:

seemed to form the closest bond with Millie, his new "big sister" (remember when he kissed her on the cheek in "Going Courting" and danced with her at the barn raising?)


I've always thought that too!

reply

Benjamin...even though he couldn't dance...;)

This is a logic free zone:
Use of logic will be met with uncomfortable silences

reply

DEFINITELY BENJAMIN!!!!

I thought Adam was handsome until I saw Benjamin. Then I had eyes only for him. At some points, I even began to think Adam was ugly in comparison. NONE of the other brothers did it for me, but I actually occasionally SIGHED when Benjamin would appear.

Hot hot.

:)~

reply

Frank and Benjamin!!

reply