MovieChat Forums > The Fountainhead (1949) Discussion > Modern Casting (Remake of The Fountainhe...

Modern Casting (Remake of The Fountainhead)


Who would you select to play Howard, Dominique, Peter, Ellsworth, Gail, and Steven Mallory?

reply

Howard- Guy Pierce
Dominique- Jennifer Connelly
Peter- Brad Pitt
Gail- Kevin Spacey
Steven- Colin Farrell
Ellsworth- John Malkovich

reply

I like all of those except Peter and Mallory. Maybe Jared Leto for Peter and Philip Seymour Hoffman for Steven maybe (if he could slim down a bit). Good picks though.

reply

I actually think Keanu Reeves might do a good job depicting Roark, to present that detachment from the norms of society.

reply

I thought about keanu as keating, but he's a bit too exotic maybe...

here's mine:

roark - brad pitt/edward norton
dominique - gwynneth paltrow
keating - jude law
toohey - a younger anthony hopkins
wynand - paul newman would be a great choice, but, well...i'll go with liam neeson, now
steven mallory - p.s. hoffman
katie - mary lynn rajskub

reply

HOWARD ROARK: Eric Stoltz (right hair color but also has that angular face and a kind of alien distance coupled with strong presence, at times) Or Ethan Hawke. Or maybe even Rupert Grint . . .
PETER KEATING: Jared Leto
GUY FRANCON: Kevin Spacey
HENRY CAMERON: Billy Bob Thornton
CATHERINE HALSEY: Chloƫ Sevigny
MRS. KEATING: Kathy Bates
ELLSWORTH TOOHEY: Anthony Hopkins

I'm still reading the book . . .

reply

I totally agree with Stoltz as Roark. Perfect style and he has got the haircolor right.

HOWARD ROARK: Eric Stoltz (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000655/)
DOMINIQUE FRANCON: Rachel McAdams (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1046097/)
PETER KEATING: Cillian Murphy (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0614165/)
ELLSWORTH TOOHEY: Hugh Laurie (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0614165/)
GAIL WYNAND: Paul Johansson (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0424035/)
GUY FRANCON: Willian Pedersen (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0614165/)
HENRY CAMERON: Anthony Hopkins (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000164/)
CATHERINE HALSEY: Chloƫ Sevigny (http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001721/)
MRS. KEATING: Kathy Bates ([url]http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000870/)


X ~We are the people our parents warned us about

reply

wynand - definitely Clint Eastwood

reply

[deleted]

I am impressed with your idea of Edward Norton and Liam Neeson for the two key parts. They might come as close to anyone in the present being able to fill the shoes of Cooper and Massey, and play the characters in the proper manner.

As one of Gwyneth Paltrow's fiercest boosters, I'm still not sure Gwyneth could do the required moments of fire. It's tough to fill the shoes of Patricia Neal. Maybe Rachel McAdams or Catherine Zeta-Jones. They could do the fire, but not sure about the other nuances. In principle Angelina Jolie can do anything you throw at her, but I just don't see Dominique in her.

reply

alas, the only truly suitable candidate for roark is john belushi, and he's not especially available. though even in his current state, he could give a more stirring performance than gary cooper. jack black tries hard, i just don't think he could pull it off. i suppose he's the next most qualified candidate.

ellsworth could be done brilliantly by jay leno. i can't think of another performer who more brilliantly encapsulates pure evil.

and dominique...well...any dinner theater actress could manage the nuances that rand wrote into the character, but i believe roseanne barr would give a performance that would go down in history as one of the greats.

reply

All way, way too old. Stick with the ages in the book, not this film.

reply

Which character was Steven Mallory?

reply

Roark - Jack Black
dominique - Maria Sharapova
keating - Hugo Weaving
toohey - james Garner
wynand - Adam Sandler
steven mallory - Robert De Niro
katie - Meryl Streep

reply

Considering this is my favorite book, I've thought about this for a long time...

Howard Roark: James Franco
Dominique Francon: Sienna Miller
Peter Keating: Jason Schwartzman
Ellsworth Toohey: J.K. Simmons
Gail Wynard: Kevin Spacey
Henry Cameron: Bill Murray
Catherine Halsey: Anne Hathaway
Mrs. Keating: Kathy Bates
Austen Heller: Jeff Goldblum
Guy Francon: John Lithgow
Stephen Mallory: Joseph Gordon-Levitt

reply

hello

I must say that your casting is right on.

I just finished the book yesterday and it just made its way onto my top ten.

I kept on fantasizing a modern-day adaptation/casting for the book including who would play who.

Roark must be elegant, well-structured, and his face must convey a million emotions without even saying a world. The latter needs to be the same for Dominique. I must say that the quarry scenes were my favorite and I would love to see that conveyed into film.

I even went on to think up movie posters. It would be something like having the actor playing Roark in a clear, serious headshot that takes up the whole poster and have the headline be: Franco is Roark, or the like. The same would go for Keating, Dominique, Toohey, etc.

It makes me itch to write a screenplay based on the book because I think it's just an amazing, mesmerizing piece of fiction, and I want to see today's stellar actors to be part of the movie. I think it'd be great.

reply

Actually, my thought was James Franco as Keating.

reply

Howard- Alan Tudyk
Dominique - Scarlett Johansson
Peter - James Franco
Ellsworth- David Hyde Pierce!!!

reply

Howard Roark - Paul Dano
Ellsworth Toohey - Sean Penn
Dominique Francon - Jennifer Connolly
Gail Wynand - Daniel Day Lewis or Hugh Laurie
Peter Keating - Mark Ruffalo
Henry Cameron - Jonh Malkovich
Catherine Halsey - Amy Adams
Guy Francon - Alan Arkin
Stephan Mallory - Shia LeBouff
Alvah Scarret - William H. Macy

srry if my spelling is all over the place...

How come every word you say is either *beep* *beep* or *beep*?

reply

[deleted]

The only one I care about is Dominique Francon. It's gotta be Catherine Zita-Jones because she seems so unattainable, you want her even more.

reply

[deleted]

Several Times

It behooves the Jews and Arabs to settle their differences in a Christian manner





reply

Roark -- Ryan Gosling
Keating -- Vincent Kartiser
Dominique -- Anna Paquin
Wynand -- Patrick Dempsey
Toohey -- Mandy Patinkin

reply

Howard Roark - Michael Shannon
Dominique Francon - Angelina Jolie
Gail Waynand - James Cromwell
Ellsworth Toohey - William H. Macy
Kaite - Anna Kendrick

reply

Someone asked who Steven Mallory was...

... and after considering it for a bit, I'm almost positive it's the 'failed' artist/sculptor whom Roark chose to sculpt the centerpiece of his all-faith temple from 3/4 along in the book.

Remember, Steven Mallory shot at Ellsworth Toohey, though he never understood why. An awesome character who deserves his own book or film.

reply