MovieChat Forums > Shadow of a Doubt (1943) Discussion > FLAW in plot really ruins this

FLAW in plot really ruins this

posted 10 years ago by aciolino
16 replies | jump to latest

If the police/FBI are so sure about Uncle Charley's guilt, or if they even have a strong suspicion, they would be in their rights to bring him in for questioning and to have his damn photo taken for I.D. purposes, and all this chicanery would be avoided.

Bad job on the part of Thurber, Hitch.

[–] SandyR (7704) 3 years ago

One of Hitchcock's last projects he never got to complete was about a film director eliminating people in the audience who nitpick about plot holes.