MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > "10 Most Controversial Disney Movies (& ...

"10 Most Controversial Disney Movies (& Why They Should Be Reimagined Today)"


https://www.cbr.com/controversial-disney-films-reimagined/

Okay, there's a lot to disagree with here.

"The Aristocats" Had Some Problematic Racial Stereotyping
Well, at least it was a cat and not a human.
But naturally, they would have to do things differently if there was a remake.
Even so, I don't see how criticizing older movies for such things is fair.
We have to learn that times change and that things were different in the past.

The Depiction Of Indigenous People Was Abhorrent In "Peter Pan"
But what if we see them as figments of the imagination of three kids from Edwardian London?
They happen to be inhabitants of a fantasy land and not real Native Americans.
But yeah, that is clearly not how a modern adaption of the story would represent them.
Still, it is yet again an opportunity to learn about history and discuss old racial stereotypes.

"Hercules" Should Coincide With Mythology
How would that be possible though?
It is not like Disney could show us how Zeus slept around or that Hercules killed his own children.

Modern Viewers Have Found "The Fox And The Hound" Sexist
But it's clear that Amos Slade isn't supposed to be a very likable character, so he wouldn't be a role model.
But I must agree that giving the widow a proper first name would have been nice...

"Pocahontas" Was Strewn With Inaccuracies
Well, the movie was based on the legend about Pocahontas rather than on real history.
And how exactly did it romanticize the European invasion, when it clearly showed that it was problematic?

"Snow White And The Seven Dwarfs" Is Overall Problematic
What is wrong with being a housekeeper and a caregiver?
And thinking of the kiss and the dwarfs that way is just overanalyzing a fairytale for no good reason.

"The Little Mermaid" Had A Problematic Message
No, it didn't.
Ariel expressed a wish to live on land already before she had laid eyes on Eric.

"Sleeping Beauty" Has One Of The Most Problematic Storylines
But I read somewhere that not getting an invitation would have been a great insult in Medieval times.
So I guess that a male villain could have reacted in the same way.
And we shouldn't forget that the movie has three likable powerful female characters in the good fairies.
And again, isn't it pointless to overanalyze a kiss in a fairytale like that?

reply

Kiss Snow White is like CPR.
The dwarfs give Snow White free food, water and lodging, the least she can do is to clean their house and she didn't even work alone, a dozens of animals help her.

reply

Yeah, people seem to be just looking for stuff to complain about sometimes.

reply

"Snow White" is problematic, because Snow White herself is drawn to look 11-12 years old... and a grown man kisses her and carries her off at the end of the film. Eew eew EEW!

https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-oKe2ws4mOcQ/VyuDe0PKTUI/AAAAAAAZf8I/1nqhGGlIPH4uQO11IyOQYzVVVvumuUejQCLcB/s1600/vlcsnap-2016-05-04-18h58m14s721.png

Her taking over the housekeeping at the dwarves' place isn't problematic, it's just unrealistic. Princesses don't do housework, their idea of "women's work", or keeping house, is to manage the servants by telling them to do a better job.

reply

She is fourteen years old, apparently.
It is of course a tiny bit older than eleven or twelve, but still too young to be carried off by a man by modern standards.
However, it wouldn't have been unheard of that a bride in Medieval times was only fourteen years old.
Now, I can see how that still would be uncomfortable to many modern viewers.
But since her age is not mentioned in the movie, it is very much possible for me to ignore that issue...

Snow White had learned to do housework since her evil stepmother had forced her to work as a scullery maid.
Her life was not that of a typical princess by that point.

reply

Fourteen and a grown man is still as icky as all hell, but the way she was originally drawn looks younger than fourteen, if the girl in the original film is 14 she's short and waaay underdeveloped for her age.

https://giffiles.alphacoders.com/977/97740.gif

Funny thing, even though the original Snow White was drawn to look like a tiny girl of 11 or 12, all of Disney's re-creations of her make her look like a young adult. I guess they realized their mistake after the fact.

reply

Sure, it is very much likely that they don't want to draw too much attention to her young age.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Why?

reply

You'd think that "Sleeping Beauty" would huge among feminist film lovers, because it's so dominated by female characters. The heroes are three dumpy middle-aged fairies, and they spend the whole film trying to save a child's life from an evil peer, and do so without compromising their ethics. And the only major male character is only on screen long enough to establish that he's worthy of their adopted child.

I really like that movie, partly for the Tchaikovsky-pastiche score, partly for the ravishing color animation, partly because it's utterly unlike other Disney movies, or other movies of that era. Not problematic at all.

reply

Well, it has indeed gotten praise for being a feminist movie.
But it seems like some people can find faults anywhere.

reply

https://www.themarysue.com/worst-disney-movies-of-all-time/1

Here's a similar article...
Now, I will not talk about most of the movies in this list since I haven't seen them.
But...

"Mulan II"
Mulan is actually against the idea that princesses should be forced into arranged marriages.
And a lot of people who dislike the movie criticize it for that reason because Mulan apparently "likes traditions".
Does it really matter which race the actor who plays a dragon in a cartoon is?
And it has been years since I saw this movie, but I don't remember any toxic masculinity from Mushu or Shang.

"Pocahontas" and "Pocahontas II".
It is hardly fair to expect cartoons to be historically correct.
But yet again, it is clearly shown that the colonization was problematic and hardly "romanticized".
It is also shown that Pocahontas doesn't do her job as an ambassador when she tries to be a European lady.
But she can convince the king to stop the armada when she wears her own clothes and her mother's necklace.

"Song of the South"
I have only seen parts of this movie, but I don't think that I ever will get why people hate it so much.
It is a family-friendly movie and wasn't going to show us anybody getting lynched or raped or something like that.
Yeah, there could have been some hints that things weren't perfect, but really, it seems to be harmless enough.
And I don't think that the black people were "bursting with joy" but just trying to make the best out of their lives...

reply