Elisha Cuthbert and Emile Hirsch had zero chemistry.

Disagree mate

She played a great role, sort of in three phases. Her changes were due to the life situations of the character 1.) Nobody knows her past 2.) Her boyfriend knows her past and she's going back into it 3.) Her boyfriend knows her past and she has a new life now.

He portrayed the correct level of naivete for who he was in the movie. He was nervous and going through love for the first time. The combination was what it should be. The chemistry was desire + awkwardness that was somehow natural. I thought the movie and the acting delivered. It's not your everyday romcom. Some of it was really subpar but the romance and how it was played was spot on IMO.

Absolutely agree, though Elisha Cuthbert almost sells it for the both of them.

They have a problem of establishing Emile Hirsch as someone of interest to her thought, and that's too bad.

Yeah, well that's true of most couples I know in real life.

uhm obvi

Emile Hirsch looks like an Orc.. and not in a good way.

disagree , I am pretty sure she liked him cuz he was kind of simple, innocent and shy , the opposite of the arrogant / loud mouth guys she would meet in her line of work , and he is rather cute not ugly like his high school two best friends for example.

I REALLY LIKE EMILE HIRSCH AND ENJOY HIS ACTING...HE SEEMS INCAPABLE OF CREATING "CHEMISTRY" WITH ANY FEMALE CO STAR THOUGH.

Agreed. The entire thing felt forced and not natural. See Jim & Michelle from American Pie to see a more convincing relationship.