I like this but ...


I do enjoy watching this mostly because despite its flaws I think Jodie Comer is really watchable and a great actress. My boyfriend and I however are both exasperated with the insensitivity of the police every episode.

I've seen there is another similar topic regarding this and l'm not surprised because it's really unrealistic.

If this actually happened, and there are some examples I can think of in Germany and the US, the sensitive procedure of dealing with the victims would be paramount. When Ivy is first rescued she is paraded all over the police station in a space suit with some random liaison officer, offered seemingly no privacy or sensitivity. She is then allowed home that afternoon like she was a teenage runaway missing for a couple of nights. Aside from what seemed like a one off hour long appointment with a psychologist she and her family are just left to their own devices? I feel like in reality the amount of preparation for a return to the normal world supervised and supported by many professionals would be the way this would be handled. Not just for Ivy but for the whole family. For a start I doubt it would be wise for the sisters fiancé to be remaining in the house when she first came back. It would be a slow process surely of everybody, esp Ivy, in overcoming fears and trust etc.

Then there is the cackhanded way Ivy is dealt with by the police in particular the female officer who from the first couple of seconds of meeting Ivy seemed to hate her and treat her like a romantic rival with the policeman instead of a young girl who had been victimised and locked up for years. It's just ridiculous. Like another poster has said, have they never heard of Stockholm syndrome or thought how terrifying it would be to go through what Ivy went through. The fear of and the infliction of violence and abuse and the threats of a murderer and rapist which is what her abductor was would be enough to silence and coerce you into submission. The way they were acting like Ivy was willing in the cctv images was a joke. Acting like she wanted to be there because she didn't run away. Ugh it's so annoying they don't seem to have an iota of understanding or compassion, from a human level or just from any police training or whatever. They are both incompetent. Also the way they act like its Ivy's fault if anything happens to phoebe is again insane. Not to mention the way she is arrested over the body. What do they expect when they half heartedly examine her and send her home that night with not so much as an in depth series of interviews and care involving professional therapists. Why would an abused kidnapped person spill her guts to a bunch of strangers treating her coldly from the start. Ridiculous.

The amount of

reply

Agreed, OP. She should have been taken to a hospital immediately, for one thing.




🐈 Rachel

reply

Pretty much summed it up for me, too. I just wanted to scream out to everyone in the show 'don't you see what is going on; don't you see what is going on????' Completely ruined the show for me!!!

reply

The police officers are too clueless. The girl was held captive for 13 years, and they are surprised that she feels something for her captor and might not tell the truth about every detail? Give me a break.

Jaan Pehechan Ho

reply

Actually I don't like this, because I can not imagine for any moment that the police would go about in this utter unprofessional way as they do in this series. It makes it totally unbelievable.

The place should be swarming with specially trained people and the case would not be handed to two officers who were first confronted with the case. I have watched now part four and part five can in no way make up for the rubbish presented as police work. (Yeah, I know about Rotherham, but that's a totally different matter, I think)

In the seventies I taught at a school for disabled children, had seven/eight guys in my class every year with muscular dystrophy type Duchenne. Every year one of them died. Within a day and an evening we, all the staff, had the protocol fixed how to deal with this news, what to say the next day and what not to say to all the other schoolkids and how to deal with the parents. That was very precise, even the words to be used were discussed. In the seventies on a school mind you.

It's now about 40/45 years later and I can not imagine that we have not advanced in this field dealing far better with severely damaged people and relations/people who will run the risk to be damaged in the process unless they receive professional pschological support. So much more is known now and that should be reflected far more in this series. Especially since the subject matter is on a quite different scale as compared to a school.

If that is not possible then don't write this storyline. Well, if the had written to happen in the fifties, it might be a tad more believeable, but even then. For Pete's sake it's happening in 2016.

In this series the psychologist seems written in as a sort of afterthought, we only learn from her findings as one of the officers breaks in to read her files. Pahleese! Gimme break! Chief Supt David Burridge says at a certain moment: "Try to be friends with her." (if I remember correctly) Just out of the blue, but perhaps he a psychologist in disguise.

I don't know if I will bother to watch the final part. I've read here that Ivy goes unwired to meet Mark White. Yeah, sure.

reply

I absolutely agree with everything Trottietrue says - 100% I need say nothing more!

reply

This show dragged along. It was poorly written. I usually like BBC shows, but this one was irritating.

reply